4 ms·
>1. A river cuts through a rock, not because of its power but it's persistence. This one annoys me, because of it's ether/or proposition when it is more of a a
by pixl97 8y ago
>1. A river cuts through a rock, not because of its power but it's persistence.
This one annoys me, because of it's ether/or proposition when it is more of a and/or function.
Yes, water including rivers cuts through rocks in more than one way. For example, Ph differences in the water can cause chemical weathering of the rock. In general these effects happen slowly and need to be persistent for any measurable effect.
But to deny the absolute power of a raging torrent and the amount of physical landscape change it is capable of in just moments is absolute folly. A swift river full of sand and chunks of rock can act like a water cutter or a sand blaster.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missoula_Floods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missoula_Floods are a testament to the power of water.
- kjeetgill 8y agoYou're right of course but you get what they _mean_ right? Persistence can be key to accomplishing something significant you don't feel capable of. Or am I being too charitable?
- wavefunction 8y agoThat specific example seems more like some combination of persistence and power is required: great power suddenly and temporarily expressed could cut through stone while a weak power expressed over a long-enough time frame would have the same effect. On it's face it's only a partially true statement and thus is effectively 'BS' when presented as an aphorism. As well, it anthropormorphizes the effect of gravity on water as 'persistence.' It might serve as a fine metaphor for human persistence but that's all.
- kjeetgill 8y agoPossibly Controversial: I think it's key to read it a specific (overly charitable?) light. You kind of have to take for granted that it's good advice in context. Someone is feeling discouraged and incapable facing come significant task and the best advice is to not be distracted by the feelings of incapability but rather persevere. If you're reading it as statement on the relationship between power and persistence .. um .. you're missing it's point. Whether you agree or think it isn't well communicated is besides the point a little bit.
- ozzy6009 8y agoI think it would sound more metaphorical if you removed the indefinite articles, instead starting with "The river cuts through rock"
- anewone 8y agoBut that doesn't emphasise why. The point is to say "keep on truckin'". If you have to spend a minute thinking about erosion first then it loses its punch.
- mcphage 8y ago> It might serve as a fine metaphor for human persistence but that's all. That's what it's intended to do. It's not trying to be a statement about Geology.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SamBam 8y agoThat seems to be entirely missing the point that it's a metaphor. It's like taking issue with another of the profound statements: "Your teacher can open the door, but you have to step in." "Well, no," you point out, "you could be carried in by the teacher. Or maybe you're in a wheelchair and you need to wheel in." The door, and stepping, in this case, are to be understood metaphorically. So is the river and the rock.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 8y agoA bloody-minded willingness to argue over meaningless technical minutiae is one of the mighty fences separating engineering from philosophy. It subtly undermines the supposedly profound statements by pointing out that there's still a little bit of bullshit in them, too. As no engineer ever said, "The house built from enlightenment has insufficient amps coming into the breaker panel." The philosopher makes a profound statement that less sophisticated thinkers can understand. The engineer just builds a hydraulic cutter that is remarkable in its system to keep the silicon carbide grit slurry from clotting in the supply lines, and asks which river rock you want sliced up. Intentionally missing the point is a form of trolling. And it's super fun when it's deflating the pomposity out of someone.
- staticautomatic 8y agoI don't think it's fair to criticize metaphor as bullshit insofar as the definition of bullshit is something like "saying things without regard for their truth values" (paraphrasing Harry Frankfurt) because metaphor doesn't have the sort of truth requirement you seem to think it does.
- bena 8y ago> It subtly undermines the supposedly profound statements by pointing out that there's still a little bit of bullshit in them, too This actually caught me and I found myself trying to game the test itself. For the first one, I was like "Yeah, it's true and is saying that persistence is important if you want to achieve your goals, but it's kind of a bullshitty way to say it" And then reading the rest, they all felt like they belonged on posters of silhouetted people looking over mighty vistas. So I declared the entire exercise a trick question. Also. Water saws are fucking scary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]