4 ms·
You make it sound like "changing the applied stress" is cheating, like they're equivocating on the problem. But the problem is just breaking spaghetti with your
by andrewflnr 8y ago
You make it sound like "changing the applied stress" is cheating, like they're equivocating on the problem. But the problem is just breaking spaghetti with your hand, by any means necessary for providing good entertainment. And challenging the unstated assumptions of a problem is often the most interesting way to solve it.
Anyway, sounds like it was interesting enough to make you do a bunch of experiments.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoIt's not that they're "cheating". It's just that many problems (like this one) are only difficult under some constraint. Lift that constraint, and it's easy (and therefore uninteresting). I'm absolutely certain that Feynmann himself discovered the same thing as I did many decades ago, and that he discarded this "solution" because it was outside of the constraints that made the problem interesting.