3 ms·
I disagree. Throughout japanese media and culture there's also the thought that "if I just try hard enough, I'll succeed" despite lack of training. This is d
by zdw 16y ago
I disagree.
Throughout japanese media and culture there's also the thought that "if I just try hard enough, I'll succeed" despite lack of training. This is demonstrably false, and similar to giving gold stars for effort.
- stcredzero 16y agoIf a major blockage is the idea that something isn't possible, then, "if I just try hard enough, I'll succeed," might indeed win the day. If what is important is skill and technique, then training might win the day. I suspect it's not one or the other all the time, rather it's one or the other depending on context. That said, at the last moment or in a crisis, training is most likely to win out, but even this is not absolute. Artillery crews were once trained to stay by their cannon to defend them at all costs. However, it was noted that in the face of counter-battery fire, most of the time the artillery onsite would all still function while the entire crew might be killed. (Guns being made of metal while people are made of red squishy stuff.) In this case, the training was wrong and those who went with their gut feelings (run like hell and take cover) were actually doing the right thing. Taking cover under counter-battery fire became the new training norm.