4 ms·
I think I should clarify what I mean by "leftism". I distinguish leftism from liberalism. Liberalism, in most English-speaking cultures today, is variously cen
by philwelch 8y ago
I think I should clarify what I mean by "leftism".
I distinguish leftism from liberalism. Liberalism, in most English-speaking cultures today, is variously centrist, center-right, or center-left in outlook. Liberalism is the ACLU lawyer who fights for both the Neo-Nazi's freedom to hold a protest march in Skokie as well as the black tenant's freedom from discrimination. Liberalism is the Enlightenment. The term "liberal", in American parlance, has been intermittently hijacked by leftists, but it is a separate tradition from leftism.
The archetypal leftists were the French peasants seated in the literal left wing of the Estates-General. The French Revolution itself was a huge mess of conflicting influences, ranging from constitutional monarchists to Enlightenment republicans to the bloody-minded Jacobins. But the grand narrative was that the commoners of France represented a social and economic class that was oppressed by the other two estates (the clergy and nobility), and rose up to overthrow their oppressors. It doesn't take a lot to turn this narrative into the Marxist narrative (where the working class overthrows the oppressive bourgeoisie). With a little bit of squinting, and by throwing out the distinctly Marxist idea that class divisions are primary to gender or ethnic divisions, this narrative turns into the left-feminist narrative (where women overthrow the oppressive patriarchy), the leftist racial narratives that mostly found full fruit in places like Zimbabwe (where People Of Color overthrow the oppressive white colonizers), and so forth.
Leftism is, in my estimation, an ideological mistake. The Jacobins didn't build a grand republic, they just killed a bunch of people until the country fell under a military dictatorship. The Marxists didn't build a grand socialist republic, they just killed a bunch of people and the countries they controlled fell under despotism. Zimbabwe turned into a basket case, while its neighbor South Africa prospered by fostering reconciliation rather than retribution towards their white population. I think it's crucial for sensible, moderate, centrist, liberal people (of which I consider myself one) to identify, reject, and repudiate this narrative. Obama has made imperfect but valiant efforts at this, while Nelson Mandela's rejection of post-colonial leftism is, in my estimation, one of the greatest acts of political heroism in recent history.
Also, yes--while right-wing and non-leftist ideologies also employ tribalism, they don't employ it within the specific context of the oppression narrative.