4 ms·
The math doesn't check out. "Each family would get more than $7,200 in annual coverage"; "better health care for 1.3 billion people" and "Modicare is expected
by PeterisP 8y ago
The math doesn't check out.
"Each family would get more than $7,200 in annual coverage"; "better health care for 1.3 billion people" and "Modicare is expected to cost the Indian government less than $2 billion annually" seem to be mutually exclusive. There's no reasonable way for health insurance/coverage to be so underutilized that on average only $1-$2 of $7200 would get used.
- onion2k 8y agoWhen they say it'll cost $2b I think that's in addition to what's already being spent.
- balladeer 8y agoYou should hear our respected PM's (PM Modi) speeches (pick pretty much any) and ruling party's (BJP) statements and you would get used to math and facts not checking out. I used to think those were just slips and mistakes. It took a couple of years for me to finally understand that those were indeed mistakes but "calculated" ones. It works like this - you declare "every household will get X by the end of 3rd year" and you know that 80% will be just euphoric to hear that and after 6 months they will forget it was 3 years - they are your fans. Once you say something they take it onto them to defend you and what you said forever, no matter how absurd it was. You will also know that out of remaining 20% like 1-2% will dig into it and out of that 1-2% a minuscule will have the guts and acumen to speak out and if they do that previous 80% will take care of this fractional percentage who speaks out either by drowning their voice with their collective noise or bully or silence them somehow. "Somehow" also includes "non-peaceful" means (very effective in silencing people).
- shripadk 8y agoCan you explain what is wrong with the math here? Are you expecting 1.3 billion people to fall ill every year? This is coverage we are talking about. I can't understand how some people don't know what coverage means.
- sn41 8y agoGreat observation. You are absolutely right. Unfortunately, the public does not care about, or understand, numbers, probability, expectation or black swans, and the politicians know that at a gut level. I wish there was a consistent way to call out such bullshit in a way that matters. But the history of humanity vis-a-vis rhetoric from the time of Demosthenes is not entirely inspiring.
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoCoverage up to X does not mean people will use X. 7200$ is a shit ton of money in India.
- PeterisP 8y agoSure, people will not use X but they'll also use more than 0.02% of X; Even a ridiculously unrealistic low utilization of 0.2% is 14$/year and would cost ten times more than the "estimated" cost.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shripadk 8y agoNo they won't. You aren't discounting those who already hold health insurance because it's a deduction for their tax returns. So for such people it's an investment. You are also not discounting those who are covered by their employers group health insurance. Not to forget those people who already have enough to spend for private healthcare. Not all 1.3 billion people in India are poor who depend on government health insurance.
- PeterisP 8y agoThese factors don't need to be explicitly discounted because they are far too small to matter. The number of people covered by various private group health insurance in India is something like 100 million, so it's just a 10% difference when we're talking about order-of-magnitude differences. Yes, not all 1.3 billion are poor and depend on government health insurance, but the numbers are so outrageously off that it doesn't work for 1.3 billion people; doesn't work for 1.0 billion people, doesn't work for 0.8 billion people (who are currently uncovered by other gov't subsidies including RSBY). Unless you're arguing that it applies to a tiny, tiny fraction of Indias population, the math doesn't work out, either the cost estimate or the benefits will be entirely different.
- deleted 8y ago
- shripadk 8y agoWhy is this so hard to understand? Why would 1.3 billion people want $7,200 in coverage at once? If that happens then it's a mega catastrophe of proportions that the entire World would not be prepared to bear. That would also mean the end of the World as we know it. So let's be realistic shall we? Of those 1.3 billion people hardly 0.1% of them might fall ill in any given year. That's 13 million people. That's still a huge number. Of them how many do you think would be critically ill? 100%? 75%? 50%? 25%? Let's take 25%. That would still be a huge number of critically ill patients (3.25 million). The total number of cancer patients in India per year is around 7 lakhs, which is 0.7 million (http://cancerindia.org.in/statistics/ http://cancerindia.org.in/statistics/) so my guesstimate of 3.25 million makes sense (even though I feel it's higher then what the actual stats are). Only such kind of people would need the $7,200 insurance because critical illness care is cheaper in India compared to any other country. You don't need $7,200 to treat malaria or flu or to get your wisdom tooth removed (https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/Wisdom-lies-in-getting-tooth-extracted-in-India/articleshow/26613578.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/Wisdom-li...). You need that kind of amount if you get cancer/stroke etc. Of those 3.25 million patients what percentage do you think are people who can afford private healthcare and those can't? Of those who can afford how many of them are covered by their employers group health insurance or have their own insurance purchased as part of tax saving initiatives? Now you do the math and you'll get your answer.
- PeterisP 8y ago"hardly 0.1% of them might fall ill in any given year" is a very unrealistic assumption - is service is available (which is not universal in India at the moment, but is promised to be with this reform) the expected number of annual per capita doctors visits is at least 1 (OECD country average is 7, poorer countries get 1-2), not 0.001, a thousandfold difference. Not all people won't get ill in a given year, but a large portion does; it depends on how severe illnesses you count but it's 30-60%, not 0.1% or 1%; and some people (much more than 0.1%) get multiple illnesses in a single year. I'm arguing that on average people (all 1.3 billion of them) need much, much more than $1 of coverage each year. You don't need $7200 to treat common diseases, but many of them will need more than $1. For every person that needs $0 of coverage there will be one that needs more than $2. If the estimate was comparable to $10 per person (so, excluding private insurance, roughly $10 billion total not $1-2 billion), then it might be worth starting a discussion about the details and how much what costs. But $1/person/year is so ridiculous that it's off the charts.