4 ms·
It's probably time for a new architecture that isn't so convoluted with decades of optimizations and iterative improvements. It's also time for a computer syst
by colechristensen 8y ago
It's probably time for a new architecture that isn't so convoluted with decades of optimizations and iterative improvements.
It's also time for a computer system with one and only one general purpose processor (no tiny CPUs in storage or "system management" or every other device)
Probably something like a programming language/OS/computer system written new with a CPU based on current GPU designs.
- slededit 8y agoYou won't make any CPU of reasonable performance without speculative execution and all the rest. Your limited by data dependencies and the only way to break them is to "cheat". Unless your willing to run on the equivalent of a Cortex-M0 then you have to live with it.
- dnautics 8y agoI hear delay slots aren't so bad, and compiler optimizations have gotten really good since the itanium days when they last (half-hearted) tried vliw
- slededit 8y agoDelay slots are merely the pipeline of the uarch peeking through, its bad practice because you'll probably want to change the pipeline depth at some point. Other uarchs have them but they hide them from the public API. VLIW only removes the logic to detect data dependency - it doesn't workaround the actual need to wait for data to be ready. None of this has much to do with speculative execution which is guessing which way a branch will go. You simply can't have what would be considered a modern computer without it.
- bonzini 8y agoThere is nothing particularly convoluted in either meltdown or this new attack. This optimization could have happened on any other architecture. The legacy parts have either been disabled in 64-bit mode, or they are implemented in microcode. Other architectures are not simple either, ARM64 has incredibly complicated paging for example.
- pjc50 8y ago> no tiny CPUs That is far more a constraint than you think. Probably quite hard to have even a gigabit Ethernet subsystem without it.
- vardump 8y agoDone that, not very hard to have just a dumb ethernet MAC with hardware rx and tx ring buffers. You could map that over PCIe just fine. Of course no offloading, but you wouldn't notice any performance drops, if the ring buffers are large enough.