4 ms·
In the US court system, a defendant is not required to refute a charge--it is the obligation of the prosecution to prove all of the elements of a given charge.
by gamblor956 8y ago
In the US court system, a defendant is not required to refute a charge--it is the obligation of the prosecution to prove all of the elements of a given charge.
However, because conspiracy is a separate crime, it can in some cases survive the voiding of the underlying crime, i.e., in this case the purported attempted murder.
- tptacek 8y agoEvidence for the charge was presented in the indictment and, I believe, at trial. The defense failed to address it. Obviously, the defense can do so because they think the evidence is prima facie unconvincing; the defense isn't obligated to overtly speak directly to it (see today's Manafort trial, in which the defense just rested without bringing a case, and the Popehat thread about why that's common in criminal cases). But we see how that worked out for Ulbricht: he was convicted and got a life sentence.
- gamblor956 8y agoWe're talking about 2 different things. The Defendant is never required to disprove a criminal charge, or any factor of a criminal charge, which is what I'm saying. However, once the prosecution has provided prima facie evidence of each factor of a criminal charge, it is generally advisable to attack the credibility/reliability of the evidence supporting that factor. Which is what you're saying. It isn't necessary for a defendant to present a defense, and in many cases defendants don't bother, since they never actually had a defense. They were simply hoping the prosecution would fail to prove its case to the jury.
- tptacek 8y agoI agree that we are talking about two different things.