3 ms·
A 16-year-old car will kill you in a crash that a new one will let you walk away from. That's one big, important factor in the new vs. used debate. One can be
by mikestew 8y ago
A 16-year-old car will kill you in a crash that a new one will let you walk away from. That's one big, important factor in the new vs. used debate.
One can be a Chicken Little to the point that I would ask, why drive at all? It's just not worth the risk. A sixteen-year-old car has airbags and designed-in crumple zones. It ain't no 2019 Volvo, but "kill you in a crash that a new one will let you walk away from" is ridiculous hyperbole.
A 2-decade-old car is going to break down at some inopportune time, like it or not, even with the best maintenance.
Brand-new cars do the same thing. In fact, I view cars like I do electronics: if it makes it through the first six months, you're probably good for 100K miles. And if it breaks down, so what? You email your "flexible hours" employer, tell them you'll miss standup this morning, then dip into the massive amount of funds you saved by not having a car payment to get it fixed. Oh, it's an inconvenience for sure, but is it worth $600/month to avoid once in a great while (or not at all, if Honda or Toyota)? Hell, our VW camper is 37 years old, and I'd rely on it to get me to work every day, and I think VW makes shitty cars. Take care of your shit, and it will take care of you, even if it's a VW.
Some are obviously so scared of breakdowns and that life-ending crash that is assuredly just around the next corner that they'll foot the $600/month (or whatever a car payment is these days) for their big-ass SUV that they make any excuse to justify. Others, IMO, manage risk much more realistically.
- mywittyname 8y agoDriving is the most dangerous thing most of us do, and we do so on a regular basis. The risks of injury in an automobile accident should absolutely weigh into the calculus of car ownership. Especially considering the staggering amount of progress made in vehicle safety in the past 10 years. If a brand new Camry saves you from a single ER visit that you would have had driving an 2008 Camry, then it's already paid for itself. It's not really any different from buying a fancy $150 toothbrush that does a better job at preventing cavities, or any of the many other purchases that statistically save you money in the long-term.
- mikestew 8y agoHow often have you considered taking the money for a new Camry and applying to any of a plethora of defensive driving schools or track schools? My thinking is that those fancy airbags only do you any good if something sets them off. But I am curious what progress you feel has been made in auto safety in the last ten years that is "staggering". By 2008, I think we got the low-hanging fruit: 1. ABS 2. Airbags 3. Side-curtain airbags 4. Sacrificial crumble zones I do not consider lane keeping and automatic braking to be "staggering" progress, but incremental. If a brand new Camry saves you from a single ER visit That is the very definition of begging the question.
- mywittyname 8y agoI used to be a fixture in the local SCCA, but my wife has been in far few accidents than me, so probably not a great use of time/money. As far as safety progress over the past ten years - 2008: SID-II Crash test dummies. These dummies are designed to simulate smaller humans (women and children). 2010: NHSTA revamps five star rating because cars became "too safe." Almost every vehicle on the road had a five star rating so they made the requirements more stringent. 2014: NHSTA adds small-overlap tests to accident ratings. Many cars failed during the first year. 2015: NHSTA revamps safety standards again, this time adding considerations for rollover and crash avoidance technology (automatic braking). Other considerations added over the past decade, but I can't find an exact date implemented for: side pole crash, fuel system integrity assurances, deformation barrier tests. There's a bunch more but I'm tired of reading research papers on teh subject. Suffice to say, advances in safety from 2008-2018 were staggering.
- mikestew 8y agoThere's a bunch more but I'm tired of reading research papers on teh subject. Well, thank you for taking the time to post what you did in response to my question.