4 ms·
> I've heard many of my coworkers joke that if they went through the interview process again they'd probably fail. I’ve heard this joke at a lot of tech compan
by ryandrake 8y ago
> I've heard many of my coworkers joke that if they went through the interview process again they'd probably fail.
I’ve heard this joke at a lot of tech companies. Also, “the hardest thing I’ve ever done at my job was pass the interview.” Just shows how divorced from day-to-day work skills interviewing has become.
I think most tech companies severely overestimate the cost of false positives, particularly in the USA where it’s trivially easy to fire someone who turns out to be a dud.
Also think it represents an opportunity: if you could reliably figure out who made it to the interview stage at these top companies but did not get an offer, you could forego your recruiting expense, simply hire all those people and likely end up with a well above average team, minus the few false positives.
- tootie 8y agoI'd be curious what the pipeline of candidates looks like at these top places. You're probably correct that they are being overly critical and rejecting plausible candidates. They may be overestimating their needs, but they are also probably inundated with overconfident chumps.
- ryandrake 8y agoI bet if you could select only the people who made it to the in-person interviews at these companies, which usually happens after multiple weed-out filters, you’d have a way-above-average cohort.
- zeveb 8y ago> I think most tech companies severely overestimate the cost of false positives, particularly in the USA where it’s trivially easy to fire someone who turns out to be a dud. I don't think that's actually true. People who are net-negative on a team may be very personable and hence emotionally difficult to fire. And of course the U.S. does have a number of protected classes, who can be very difficult & expensive to fire for cause (because the assumption is that they were not fired for cause). I'm a member of a protected class, and I often worry that it actually makes it more difficult for me to get hired: will folks be willing to take a chance on me, knowing that were I a jerk I could make life difficult for them? I'm not a jerk (I think!), but they can hardly know that!
- vonmoltke 8y ago> People who are net-negative on a team may be very personable and hence emotionally difficult to fire. Those people are rare and generally caught by much lighter screening. > And of course the U.S. does have a number of protected classes, who can be very difficult & expensive to fire for cause (because the assumption is that they were not fired for cause). I don't think you are using "for cause" in the proper legal sense. Firing "for cause" is indeed an time-consuming and potentially expensive process because of the effects on things like unemployment benefits. Firing "without cause" is not, and is permissible in almost every state. What you are describing are potential accusations of illegal discrimination. This is largely orthogonal to cause.
- Arcten 8y ago>I'm a member of a protected class [...] Technically speaking, we all are, no? We all have genders, sexual orientations, races, ethnicities? Of course you probably meant that you fall into a minority group in one of those classes, but pretty much anyone could allege they were discriminated against based on their protected characteristics, even if sometimes it's not a particularly believable claim.
- starpilot 8y agoTech interviews, coming from someone transitioning into the field, are blowing me away. One national retailer I spoke to does two phone screens, then an onsite round with nine coworkers. I've never seen anything like this in my previous field (mechanical engineering).
- kamaal 8y agoIts quite common in the tech area. Some teams in FANG companies(and wannabe FANG companies) are known to reject a candidate even if a single interviewer gives a bad feedback. Like say they did 9 rounds of interviews, and then they do a bar raiser round. They still reject you even if one single interviewer gave a bad feedback. There is also a concept of 'machine coding round' in a few companies here in Bangalore. Where you are given like an hour to implement sort of like fairly medium application. You could write a perfectly working application, but if the evaluator thinks its not simple or complicated for their taste, its still a straight reject. Its almost like they want cookie cut candidates who practiced interviewing day in and out for years. The real practical world experience is largely considered useless.