3 ms·
The mining cost shouldn't really have any bearing though - mining cost follows from market valuation, not the other way round. If the market goes up, it becomes
by Nursie 8y ago
The mining cost shouldn't really have any bearing though - mining cost follows from market valuation, not the other way round. If the market goes up, it becomes more profitable to mine, more people start to mine, the mining cost rises to meet the new value.
But there's no feedback to the market if, for instance, power prices go up and mining becomes more expensive. The least efficient miners must simply either mine at a loss, or drop off until difficulty readjusts downward and those who are left are back in profit. More expensive power wouldn't affect the market price of a bitcoin.
--edit-- Because it doesn't affect the supply, the same number are created either way.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> More expensive power wouldn't affect the market price of a bitcoin This seems intuitively wrong. Production and marginal costs are always factors. If power goes up in value, it becomes more expensive to produce new Bitcoins as well as process transactions. That would feed into prices, fees and usage. The strength of this signal might be obscured by noise, but that doesn't mean it isn't there.
- Nursie 8y ago> This seems intuitively wrong. But it's still correct - there is no link there. > If power goes up in value, it becomes more expensive to produce new Bitcoins as well as process transactions. No it doesn't, because the number of bitcoins produced is a constant regardless of price, and they can only be sold at market price. If people stop mining because it costs too much, the supply to the market is entirely unaffected. The cost of power has absolutely no bearing on the transaction fees or the transaction processing capabilities of the network either. Only congestion affects transaction costs, and the transaction capacity of the network is not connected to the number of miners online or the hash rate, it is roughly constant and dependent on protocol factors. --edit-- - Replying to the child post here as I am rate limited :( > If power costs go up 10x, the cost of operating the rigs that verify transactions goes up. Miners who find processing transactions unprofitable will remove themselves from the system If those miners remove themselves, it has no bearing on the rate at which transactions can be processed or the price of a transaction. They are all trying to validate the same transactions in parallel. The network does not get more capable as you add mining capacity. > until transaction fees rise to a level that pays the bill. What mechanism would cause the fees to rise? (--edit-- last edit - I think what you're missing is that as the number of miners decreases, each miner gets a bigger share of block rewards and fees)
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The cost of power has absolutely no bearing on the transaction fees If power costs go up 10x, the cost of operating the rigs that verify transactions goes up. Miners who find processing transactions unprofitable will remove themselves from the system until transaction fees rise to a level that pays the bill.
- gizmo686 8y agoNo. 90% of the miners will leave, causing the 10% that stay to see a 10x increase in revenue. There will be some short term effects as you describe until the difficulty adjusts.
- SI_Rob 8y agoIndeed it actually may help lower the noise floor, as it would expose (through unusually precise, if idiosyncratic electron-counting metrics) the real cost of power expressed by inputs from both the acknowledged market, and the unacknowledged market.
- dlubarov 8y ago> If power goes up in value, it becomes more expensive to produce new Bitcoins as well as process transactions. Difficulty is adjusted every 2016 blocks based on the timing of previous blocks. So in the long term, the rate of block creation stays constant, averaging 1 block per 10 minutes.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> in the long term, the rate of block creation stays constant Consider Bitcoin if there were a single miner running a single rig. They sink costs into the rig, and then run it, paying for electricity as it hums. The rig has to produce at least as much income to this miner as she pays out in electricity costs. Otherwise, it's more profitable to turn it off. So if electricity prices go up, income has to as well. If it doesn't, the rig goes off. This is fundamental to profit being equal to revenue minus costs. In a networked state, there are more interaction effects but the fundamental relationship holds. Every miner must pay, directly or indirectly, their electricity costs. (More than that, every user has to pay electricity costs. If electricity prices skyrocketed, an electronic currency--whether digital dollars or Bitcoin--becomes fundamentally uncompetitive relative to paper.) Constant-rate production dampens this effect, but does not remove it. At the end of the day, somebody is paying for the electricity the network consumes. Those somebodies aren't doing it for free.
- Zalastax 8y agoThe thing is that the act of mining isn't actually providing any value, it just proves that you have wasted some amount of processing power. This is called proof of work and is a system set in place so that bad actors can't take control of the ledger without spending a large amount of money. The threshold for how much work you need to put in is adjusted automatically. If there was just a single machine in the system they could choose to mine very slowly and the system would eventually reach a very easy threshold. What that means is that the threshold would be about ten times lower if electricity prices were ten times higher globally. As you can understand, this is a big big waste - which is why alternatives to proof of work are researched heavily.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dandare 8y agoHonest question: what is affected by the mining capacity? The speed of transactions? The price of transactions? The creation of new coins?
- tim333 8y agoI'm hazy here and may be wrong but: When bitcoin started there was basically one computer mining and the difficulty level reflected that and the cost of a bitcoin was less than a cent. Now that there is billions of dollars worth of hardware dedicated to mining, the difficulty level goes up until the rate of block creation is one every 10 minutes. But now the 12.5 bitcoin reward every 10 min has to support billions in capital investment hence the price needed being higher, of the order of $2000. I guess if the price fell well below that to say $100 then there would be a lot of mining hardware repurposed or sold on eBay and we could get cheap graphics cards again. re The speed of transactions? The price of transactions? The creation of new coins? The speed remains about the same, the price of transactions tends to go up, the creation of new coins is not effected as it is hard coded in the bitcoin software. (https://www.anythingcrypto.com/guides/bitcoin-mining-block-rewards-2018 https://www.anythingcrypto.com/guides/bitcoin-mining-block-r...)
- ehrtt 8y agoSecurity against double spends.
- Nursie 8y ago> what is affected by the mining capacity? The speed of transactions? The price of transactions? The creation of new coins? None of the above. More miners means more people splitting the block rewards, and more network security against 51% attacks. Literally nothing else is affected.