3 ms·
> “When asked, Facebook officials told us only immutable characteristics and traits that people are born with warrant special protection. Being a migrant is not
by ryandrake 8y ago
> “When asked, Facebook officials told us only immutable characteristics and traits that people are born with warrant special protection. Being a migrant is not such a trait, therefore freedom of speech takes priority."
Oddly, to illustrate this, the article compared the words “Muslim” with “Migrant” noting one word is protected and one not. How is someone’s religious choice considered an immutable and “born with” trait?
EDIT
This is the trouble when you start to try to “moderate” content according to some moral, as opposed to legal, standard: you inevitably end up creating this huge, complicated tree of rules that are often inconsistent and conflict with themselves, need to be interpreted and argued about, and frequently require escalation to more senior people when there is disagreement.
I’d love to see the financial justification for all this expensive moderation.
- 1996 8y agoGood catch! Beliefs are mutable. Financial justification: people who believe in $deity are probably over 80% of the facebook userbase. Can't make money with angry users, so they consider beliefs immutable.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> This is the trouble when you start to try to “moderate” content according to some moral, as opposed to legal, standard: you inevitably end up creating this huge, complicated tree of rules that are often inconsistent and conflict with themselves, need to be interpreted and argued about, and frequently require escalation to more senior people when there is disagreement. That's absolutely not a result of using a moral standard as opposed to a legal standard. I mean, that description is word-for-word applicable to legal standards, too.
- Viliam1234 8y ago> How is someone’s religious choice considered an immutable and “born with” trait? If the penalty for changing your religion is death, then it is almost immutable. And children usually don't have much choice about the religion, so it is almost as if they were born with it. Just playing a Devil's advocate.
- megous 8y agoYes, the world is complicated. :) But it would still not be a born with trait. Perhaps some propensity to accept religious beliefs might be a born with trait. People can also say something and think a differnt thing. Also while someone may identify with Islam, it could mean very differnt things in real terms, as you can see from various sects and interpretations, and real world behavior of believers. So what is really being protected? Also, clearly if you are a ISIS member, your religion is not a protected trait despite many of the memebers being quite Islamist, idealistic and devoted to the ideas much more than many of the regular muslims. Your attitudes toward religion are suddenly also not viewed as unchangeable, if you look at various deradicalisation programs. Not by anyone, mind you, there are people who think that all ISIS memebers should just be killed, and that that's the only way.