3 ms·
If I, speaking with clear will and mind, declare that I never want to be treated against my will, (fully aware of the consequences) then I want this to be respe
by hutzlibu 8y ago
If I, speaking with clear will and mind, declare that I never want to be treated against my will, (fully aware of the consequences) then I want this to be respected.
Otherwise all talks of freedom in our society is not worth the paper to write it down.
Now why am I so sceptical?
Well, first of all, declaring people mentally ill, was and is a common way to get rid of dissidents, or to get the money of a rich relative who don't want to die soon, or even consideres giving the money to a charity or alime
Sources to the last one I don't have at hand, but putting people away who were annoying, was not only done in soviet russia, but even happened (or happens?) in germany.
(https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steuerfahnder-Affäre https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steuerfahnder-Affäre or
https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustl_Mollath https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustl_Mollath German
basically, tax investigators went after some too powerful - which backfired. So even pro-government people got declared mentally ill and were locked away)
Then secondly, the human brain is not really understood. I have high respect for psychoanalysis and neurobiology, though, but I am highly sceptical, that they really understand, what they are doing. As far as I know, also the term schizophrenia is highly disputed.
And I also know, that the common psychatrist is just bad. At least the quite some cases I knew about. (I know people working in that area).
Standard procedure is calming them down with pills ... and keeping it that way.
No thank you.
If I would see myself getting ill (it does not happen overnight), I would go seek a good doctor by myself. But if I choose to do what I do, it is my decision. Even if I would endanger my body - my body, my life.
Only if I would be a danger to other people ... well then society does, what it ordinary does with dangerous people, locking them away, until they are not a threat anymore.
- houjo 8y agoWell...dangerous or violence doesn't mean just doing physical damage to person or property, which is what makes the whole issue ambiguous. There are lot of people out there, who damage the people they deal with psycologically.
- hutzlibu 8y ago"There are lot of people out there, who damage the people they deal with psycologically." That totally blures the line. Yes, there are tons of people out there who attack me psycologically with their stupidy, attempted dominace, insults, etc. But I don't think a law against stupidity would help. Sounds a bit sarcarstic? Maybe, but listening to people sometimes (on TV for example) literally causes me pain. But more specifically on topic, yes, I know also the situation when a mentally troubled person hurts the people around them who suffer see him suffering. But it still is (or was) his life.
- ptero 8y agoI think you hit the nail on the head and I personally agree 100% with your position: the society does not have the right to forcefully medicate unless I am a danger to others. Doubly so if I clearly expressed that desire while being medically sane. If contested (as it seems to be), this should be a topic of open, public discussion. And I hope that the logic that "we will do X to you against your wishes because it is good for you" will be rejected by the majority. We do not let parents take adult kids' money "'cause we know better how it should be spent", etc. Restricting individual freedoms this way is, to me, a wrong path to take, but opponents should certainly present counter cases. Restricting freedom when one is danger to others (e.g., carrying a deadly, contagious disease) is OK in my book.
- specialist 8y agoMy sis and I are currently caring for three relatives who are doing self-harm. And all that entails, including denial, neglect, selfishness. While I have been coaching my sis, eg "If Sally doesn't want to do chemo, then we have to respect her decision.", I needed to be coached in turn. So I've been seeing a counselor who has much experience with addiction and end of life stuff. Not for my own grieving or processing (much), but I really need advice refreshers, and sanity checks, and updates on best available science to help me (us) strategize. The basic advice comes down to 1) first take care of yourself 2) don't judge 3) don't try to fix, just support and empathize 4) there may come moments of lucidity where the "patient" does ask for help and is open to suggestions, so be patient and be ready. I now see great parallels between addiction, denial, cults, and how people face end of life. Mostly in how we relate to those we love who are going thru those experiences. Which will be ourselves one day, so be advised. You wrote: "... I would go seek a good doctor by myself." I strongly encourage everyone to have a patient advocate accompany them. Best available science (as of 10 years ago?) was that this significantly improves outcomes. While I was still volunteering, how it typical works is a) pre-meet with my buddy, compile list of issues and questions b) take notes during visit with doctor, play wallflower as much as possible (it's not about you), nudge patient to keep convo on track and ensure all questions get asked c) review notes and action steps Your patient advocate will (should) keep you focused and accountable. People are notoriously bad at self-reporting (eg "how long have have you experienced this discomfort?", "um, I dunno"), so advocates are also observers, verifiers. The advocate gig isn't easy. My sis and I are trying to help our mom. But she's early stage dementia, has terrible short term memory, and has a history of not asking for help (stoicism). So we don't get looped into the convos until issues become crisis. Alas, mom's not quite to the point where we can start making decisions for her, so we just have to tough it out. With an emphasis on respecting her wishes and integrity. So I just try to follow my own advice: "Mom, what do you want, need? Maybe we can help." PS- A former sweetie of mine was likely paranoid schizophrenic. My efforts to connect with, help her started my learning on that facet of this topic. I failed her and she remains untreated. I'm hoping that I'll do better, be more useful next time.