7 ms·
> Chinese fabricated financials can be papered over with any kind of magic the state wants to apply to it - so long as the economy continues to move forward the
by Gibbon1 8y ago
> Chinese fabricated financials can be papered over with any kind of magic the state wants to apply to it - so long as the economy continues to move forward the numbers will say anything they want them to say.
My feeling is business people and economists are upset that China utterly refuses to follow neoliberal economic polices. Preferring instead to follow old school Keynesian policies. Policy makers thus view China as economically in a state of sin.
Typically countries that try to follow Keynesian economic policies get hammered by western central banks and monetary institutions. However China is way both too large to be 'punished' like that and has iron fisted control of it's own currency. That leaves western and in particular US monetary authorities powerless to do anything.
Hence the constant butthurt blather for the last 30 years that that Chinese expansion only has 5 more years left before it collapses.
Notable: In 2008 the US and Europe followed neoliberal austerity policies to make sure that the banks and paper wealth were made whole. Resulting in a very slow recovery and increasing poverty and political blow back. China responded by building the worlds largest high speed rail network.
- mr_toad 8y agoChina’s external debt to GDP is one of the lowest in the world, as is their debt per capita. They aren’t going to be ‘punished’ by creditors because they don’t have significant debt. In fact, it’s more likely that China will be the one doing the punishing down the road.
- dnomad 8y agoThis is what really irks the West. China did not allow themselves to be controlled by external debt like the Soviet Union. The Chinese have not only avoided debt slavery they have actually begun to weaponize their own debt power and such that they are now the world's largest sovereign lender.
- User23 8y agoThe US doesn't borrow money from China. The US swaps treasuries for reserves with the Federal Reserve, which then sells those treasuries to primary dealers, who in turn sell them on the open market where anyone including foreign sovereigns like China, can buy them. In the unlikely event that the Federal Reserve failed to sell those instruments, they'd be left on their balance sheet and the interest would be remitted back to the US treasury. So long as there is any demand for US dollars though, there will always be a demand for interest bearing instruments that have near cash-like liquidity. Of course if you're referring to China's African colonies and their use of debt to control the local governments, then yes that's accurate.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's the same thing as borrowing. US gov sells TBills, those TBills are bought by China. The transaction you described also translates government debt into currency, which China also sits on, so it's a kind of an exchange debt. So the US 'owes' China a gazillion dollars in services and stuff. One way or another.
- User23 8y agoThis is hard to wrap one's head around, so let me try again with some more detail. The US doesn't sell TBills. It creates those interest bearing IOUs ex nihilo, and then swaps them for reserves (also created ex nihilo) with the Federal Reserve. Primary Dealers buy treasuries from the Fed, not from the treasury.[1] The process is absolutely nothing like going to a bank or anyone else to borrow money. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_dealer#Primary_dealers_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_dealer#Primary_dealers...
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYes, I get it - but the mechanism does not matter: TBills and TBonds US government debt. US dollars are a form of debt to the US economy. So If you hold TBills/TBonds, the US government owes you money. If you hold USD, then the US economy owes you 'stuff' that you can exchange those dollars for. Anyone who holds TBills/TBonds is lending to the US Government. China holds a lot of both, ergo the US is indebted to them ... essentially, the US does borrow money from China. Though the sale may not be directly to China, ultimately, that's who's sitting on those bonds/cash.
- User23 8y ago"the mechanism does not matter" only if you have no interest in understanding how the system actually works. China isn't the US's lender and they do not make any loans. They can't foreclose, because no loan exists. All they can do is take their coupons or sell the security to someone else who will do the same. China can't starve the Treasury of money because the Treasury exclusively borrows reserves from the Federal Reserve. Also worth noting is that with the stroke of a pen Congress and the President acting in concert could restore the Treasury's power to spend money into existence directly. The US creates securities as a matter of public policy, not because it actually needs them to finance itself.
- myrandomcomment 8y agoThe issue is the China's corporate debt and off book debt to government owned / backed companies. They have $3.12T coming due in the next year. For example: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-07-18/a-china-borrower-s-11-billion-debt-mountain-comes-crashing-down https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-07-18/a-china-b...
- chewz 8y ago> Designed to handle 320 trains a day, the Lanzhou-Xinjiang HSR currently has only eight daily services. “Because of this large amount of idle capacity, [the line’s] annual revenues are not enough to pay for its electricity costs,” said Prof Zhao. https://www.ft.com/content/ca28f58a-955d-11e8-b747-fb1e803ee64e https://www.ft.com/content/ca28f58a-955d-11e8-b747-fb1e803ee... [Paywall] > China’s huge leveraged bet on HSR has also generated many other benefits as it dramatically shrinks distances, transforms lives and boosts regional economies. The now three-hour, 1,100km train ride between Guangzhou and Wuhan used to take 11 hours, and tickets are now priced at just Rmb464. Annual travel on China’s HSR lines — 1.7bn trips — exceeds travel on conventional rail services. And about half of all HSR trips are, like Mr Liu’s, business-related. “When you think about that, a staggering 850m people are travelling [on HSR] to meet customers, get to their job, visit research centres and so on,” said Mr Ollivier. If China Railway’s HSR network is ultimately able to pay for itself, it will be a testament to the miracles that can happen when the Chinese Communist party marshals the vast financial resources at its disposal to serve a common good. But if it cannot, there is little doubt who will have to make up the difference. “China Railway’s debt is government-backed,” said Prof Li. “It won’t default.”
- thedailymail 8y agoBesides Keynes and obviously Marx, China's nationalist economics policies have been strongly influenced by Friedrich List (who also inspired economic development in Japan).
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI think both your assertions are not correct. Economists just want 'real' numbers from China, numbers that reflect some kind of reality. That's before any ideology sits in. If there were at least transparency there, we'd all be better off, that said if there were, the 'fudges' necessary to make things worse would be more obviously lies. As far as 2008 - this was a failure of integrity from the bottom to the top: those taking home loans, mortgage lending staff, executives, those bundling up crap, the ratings agencies, and the laziness of those buying the bundles. It was a systematic failure of reason as well. Were actual, material numbers to have been objectively published, we wouldn't have had a crisis in 2008, because nobody would have bought bundles of crap, and the market would have needed no correction because it wouldn't have gotten out of hand. China's central policies surely irk some, of course they can do it if they please, but they cant reasonably contend to be 'free trade' or what not so long as there is such government intervention; they should not be in the WTO. Everyone in the world would benefit from more objective clarity on all of this.
- danmaz74 8y ago> Were actual, material numbers to have been objectively published, we wouldn't have had a crisis in 2008, because nobody would have bought bundles of crap, and the market would have needed no correction because it wouldn't have gotten out of hand. This is circular reasoning. The market works on the information that is available at a given time, which includes all the fudging of numbers that salespeople and marketers do as part of their quest for maximising their individual interest - being handsomely rewarded by the market for this.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNo, it's not circular logic. Lying to the public, to the government, false reporting is illegal, and against a lot of other controls and regulations that are in place to support a healthy free market. There is a lot of information that does not have to be made public and people can do as they please with it - but this was not the cause of 2008, for the most part.
- 8y ago
- CryptoPunk 8y ago>>My feeling is business people and economists are upset that China utterly refuses to follow neoliberal economic polices. >>Typically countries that try to follow Keynesian economic policies get hammered by western central banks and monetary institutions. This is a common trope/conspiracy-theory that's not substantiated by the numbers. Western countries don't follow neo-liberal economic policy, unless you consider an increasingly powerful and unaccountable regulatory state, growing social welfare spending provided at the taxpayer's expense, and interventionist central bank policy, to the tune of the Federal Reserve holding $4.5 trillion in assets now, "neoliberal". By any broad-based metric of economic freedom, the West has been growing less economically liberal over the last 50 years.