3 ms·
> Also, a back of the napkin look at their changes probably means it was half to two thirds the die size, so a pretty good win at those volumes. There is no ch
by bsder 8y ago
> Also, a back of the napkin look at their changes probably means it was half to two thirds the die size, so a pretty good win at those volumes.
There is no chance that removing Y and its instructions saved 50% die area on a chip with 80K ROM and 128 bytes of RAM. The "savings" is likely due to this being in a 350nm or 500nm process rather than anything else.
Seeing as this is a cheap Chinese fabless company and these things were Chip-on-Board, they had a failure on the Y register and just datasheeted it into compliance. This is little different from the original 6502 which datasheeted the lack of Rotate Right into compliance on the first versions.
If it's cheap enough, nobody cares.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoMaybe, but removing Y also means removing the instructions which do indirect addressing through it, which removes all the decoding logic for them. So it could very well save a bunch of die space. Of course one could go look at the layout of the (NMOS) 6502, which has been fully reverse engineered at this point, to prove or disprove this.
- bsder 8y agoHere's a picture with some labels: http://breaknes.com/files/6502/6502.jpg http://breaknes.com/files/6502/6502.jpg The Y register is WAY smaller than even I expected. It's a tiny vertical strip on the lower left. And the PLA entries are on top, and a couple entries would again be tiny. Any savings due to omitting Y would be miniscule. The more I examine it in detail, the more it becomes clear that it's just a bug that got datasheeted.