2 ms·
> "I strongly disagree with the confirmation dialogs' Cancel button: confirmation dialogs are generally pointless and annoying. It's far better to provide a mea
by potatolicious 16y ago
> "I strongly disagree with the confirmation dialogs' Cancel button: confirmation dialogs are generally pointless and annoying. It's far better to provide a means of undoing."
There are some places where it's appropriate - but IMHO they should never be named "OK" and "Cancel". One of the better things we've done to make our lives easier is the trend to verb our dialog buttons, and "OK/Cancel" is in gross violation of that.
OK to what? Cancel to what? People simply don't read dialogs (or, your dialog text is just not as understandable as you think it is).
"Are you sure you want to foo?" should be followed by "Foo" and "Don't Foo", not "OK" and "Cancel".
- lotharbot 16y agoThis point cannot be stated strongly enough. The buttons should describe what you're doing, not merely affirm or reject what's in the text box. People are trained to hit "cancel" or "no" whenever unexpected text boxes come up, and "yes" if they're expecting it, without reading. This often leads to them doing the opposite of what they intended. Wording it as [Foo] and [Don't Foo] is a good start, but sometimes it should be worded as [Foo] and [Bar] where Bar is opposite of Foo. For example, [Quit] and [Continue], or [Leave] and [Stay]. EDIT: an example of the wrong way to do it: "Press OK to stay on the current page, or Cancel to receive 50% off!" http://failblog.org/2010/10/08/epic-fail-photos-cancel-fail/ http://failblog.org/2010/10/08/epic-fail-photos-cancel-fail/
- nailer 16y agoAgreed. Say I quit a long running job. And a menu comes up asking me ok or cancel. I want to quit the job, so I cancel, right? Oops, that cancels the quitting, not the job, . quit job or coninue job would mean more than ok or cancel.