3 ms·
"Kodi" is an open source media player. Nothing more or less. The problem comes because people sell boxes preloaded with Kodi and plugins that make one-click pi
by LeoPanthera 8y ago
"Kodi" is an open source media player. Nothing more or less.
The problem comes because people sell boxes preloaded with Kodi and plugins that make one-click piracy possible.
Unfortunately the association that people make is now "Kodi = Piracy", which is very wrong.
- bubblethink 8y ago>Unfortunately the association that people make is now "Kodi = Piracy", which is very wrong. Why is that association so wrong ? I mean, I would rather people fight fundamental issues like censorship on sales platforms for arbitrary reasons, instead of trying to sugarcoat it with stuff like, "yes, but it's only OSS software". For one, other than music, there is no real mass-market way to download DRM free popular media. Ripping your own DVDS/Blu-rays doesn't count, because that's still piracy (according to the US anyway). So instead of fighting the battle on whether this is piracy, and this isn't piracy, why not just say fuck it, and fight for the right to make and sell whatever device you want to and do whatever the fuck you want to with it.
- aslkdjaslkdj1 8y agoUnfortunately the piracy users for kodi now far out-strip the non-piracy users and so kodi gets de-facto associated with piracy. Just like mp3 CDs and bit torrent, when the single biggest mass market appeal for your product is piracy then the product gets associated with piracy.
- NullPrefix 8y agoIs WinAmp a piracy player?
- Spivak 8y agoAnd BitTorrent is a P2P file sharing program but it doesn't suddenly make the verb 'torrenting' mean anything other than piracy. Kodi is a fantastic piece of software and it's a shame that their brand is being tarnished but c'est la vie when that's the biggest practical use case for your program. There's no sense for anyone other than the XBMC foundation to fight the river on this one. What I would do if I was the project lead: - Pick a new name or go back to XBMC since it still has plenty of mindshare. - Implement a proper store for plug-ins and require signing for them to run a la Firefox. - Let users sideload plug-ins by running in 'unbranded mode' and aggressively litigate people using your trademark for unlocked devices. - Partner with manufacturers for an authorized device part of your store. - Work with content providers to add official apps to your store a la Chromecast.
- whalesalad 8y agoYour recommendations more-or-less came to fruition as the company Plex.
- bubblethink 8y agoI find the dichotomy quite interesting. Fundamentally, there aren't too many differences between the two, and yet Plex has no stigma associated with it. It's a pretty limited space to work in. Long term, I don't see how Plex's business model works. Since they don't control the media, they don't really control anything. There's only limited appetite for transcoding software.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoPlex relies on a backend server, on your LAN, to work. So you can't sell standalone Plex boxes, or if you did, it would have to include both the server and the client together, and the server requires a reasonably powerful system. A Raspberry Pi wouldn't be good enough.
- bubblethink 8y agoYou can run the server and client on the same box. It's just pointless for that use case, because Kodi can do that better. Plex is useful for transcoding for different clients. Besides, Plex is proprietary and can't be sold without permission. However, the point I was making was that all these things are for watching primarily pirated media, but Plex doesn't have the stigma. Plex was originally a fork of xbmc btw.
- chaz6 8y agoQuite so, they could just as well ban sales of mobile phones and computers since they also enable copyright infringement.