2 ms·
Matching noise in plots isn't proof of fraud, but it's something that is so suspicious that it changes the game from "convince me that this paper is fraudulent"
by jcranmer 8y ago
Matching noise in plots isn't proof of fraud, but it's something that is so suspicious that it changes the game from "convince me that this paper is fraudulent" to "convince me that this paper isn't fraud." In that light, other worrisome elements of the situation are problematic:
* Claiming one of the holy grail properties of modern physics is achievable with rather pedestrian materials.
* The methodology section is apparently on the vague side. Sort of on the order of “we prepared silver nanoparticles using standard techniques, then incorporated them into into a gold matrix.”
* Response to the announcement of "your data presentation has serious errors" is "we won't share our raw data to confirm."