3 ms·
Yet, I feel like frequently people do the same to "train" dogs. Apologies, the concept is so foreign to me at this point (as a result of training <g>) I just d
by mikestew 8y ago
Yet, I feel like frequently people do the same to "train" dogs.
Apologies, the concept is so foreign to me at this point (as a result of training <g>) I just didn't consider that. But you're right, folks do attempt to train dogs in that manner. I suppose it would be like lifting weights for that big marathon you have coming up. If you ask me, a runner, if that's training I would say no. But I'm fixated on the specificity. More accurately, I'd have to admit that it is, indeed, "training".
But without that specificity, it degrades to semantics. I mean, c'mon, who thinks solely lifting weights is going to get you to the finish line? When I say I'm training for a marathon, the vast majority of people would assume I'm spending most of my time running. And when I say I'm training my dog, I imagine most folks expect something along the lines of "when I say a specific command, the dog takes a specific action". Because the desired outcome of training generally is not "the dog's butt hit's the ground", the desired outcome is "I say 'sit', and the dog's butt hit's the ground". If folks are content to have a dog sit with non-specific inputs, they are free to call it whatever they like. But it is not what most people call "training", and no professional trainer would consider it to be "training".