6 ms·
> Most have less than $20,000 but some have much more. The average account balance is $67,891 It is amazing that the median is under $20k and the average is ne
by gnicholas 8y ago
> Most have less than $20,000 but some have much more. The average account balance is $67,891
It is amazing that the median is under $20k and the average is nearly $70k. This means there are some folks with very large retirement savings that are pulling the average up a lot. Considering this only includes folks up to age 32, this is really surprising. How much do these savers have socked away?
Even when I worked in a big law firm, I didn't put that much in my retirement account because I was mostly saving to be able to buy a house (in the Bay Area). I can't imagine who these millennials are that have so much in a retirement account — presumably they also live in expensive areas if they are able to earn so much?
Edit: Glad to see all the responses, including from folks who have healthy retirement accounts. It would be great if you could share where you live and whether you have bought or are planning to buy a home.
- dogma1138 8y agoIn in the UK my pension deposit is 24.5% of my pre tax salary that said this isn’t money I can touch for an emergency.
- dingaling 8y agoThat's always been my objection to pension arrangements in the UK. It's a cushy deal between the Government and financial institutions to lock-away money for 30+ years, and then tax the contributor when he becomes eligible to access it. Pensions should be tax-exempt at withdrawal, or else be accessible. Otherwise what's the incentive, other than when pre-tax contributions are possible?
- dogma1138 8y agoI agree, luckily I'm not a British citizen but as there is a tax agreement between the 2 countries I can move all my pension contributions outside of the UK without any tax. The pension tax deduction is also pretty poor and for every pound you earn above 100K you are losing your allowance which also infuriates me.
- knuththetruth 8y agoOr they have trust funds, inheritances, profited from dead parents home sales, etc.
- 2trill2spill 8y agoI save at least 15% of my salary and I live in a moderately priced city(Minneapolis). For me the biggest reasons for having a large 401K is starting early, the employer match, the S&P 500 performing well and the lowish cost of living, and of course a solid salary.
- nrhk 8y agoI'm assuming those are IB, Consulting grads at top undergrad business schools along with top undergrad engineers from the top 20. All three are raking in 100k+ starting at 22. Some of us also have parents who live close enough to major cities so saving on 1-2k a month on rent. There's a massive split in the millennial. There's a 0.1% who have parents rich enough that nothing matters, the 9.9% who are snapping up the competitive professional jobs and the 90% who are just trying to survive and start a career.
- NTDF9 8y ago>> It is amazing that the median is under $20k and the average is nearly $70k. This means there are some folks with very large retirement savings that are pulling the average up a lot. I am 30 and I have about $140k in 401k. EDIT: Why the downvotes? I'm just affirming with a datapoint. There is an extreme inequality in America and I'm willingly acknowledging that.
- gnicholas 8y agoI didn't downvote, but assume it's because one datapoint is not meaningful, and it comes across as immodest.
- sdinsn 8y agoKeep in mind compound growth. Over the last 5 years, S&P 500 is up almost 100%.
- baq 8y agoBut don't forget that past performance is not a predictor of future results. It may crash 50% in a month. Don't take growth for granted.
- ryandrake 8y agoThe majority of workers under 32 have not worked through a bear market yet, let alone lost a significant chunk of savings to one.
- zokier 8y agoIs Zuckerberg a millenial?
- gnicholas 8y agoHe's now 34, though the study was released earlier this year and carried out sometime before then. But it would be very unlikely that he would have been one of the respondents in the study :) Edit: apparently based of census data from 2014, so yeah he could be in there!
- jartelt 8y agoEngineer graduates from a Big Ten school can make a solid salary and have a very nice cost of living if they stay in the midwest. If you and your spouse bring in a combined >$150k a year and buy a house that costs <$400k, you can have a good amount saved away by the time you are 32 (10 years of working).
- dsnuh 8y agoIt was 10 years ago that I was 32, but at that point in time I had over $100K easily in my 401K. By the time I divorced three years ago, I had over $200K in there. After the divorce, I have about $20K left after having to split it with my ex-wife, who had saved a grand total of $2.00 during our marriage. I don't really have a point, except that some people are very good at saving, even from a young age, and some people will never save a penny. The key is starting young. As soon as you are able to contribute anything, even 1%, you get the advantage of compounding interest over time, which is the key.
- gnicholas 8y agoOut of curiosity, where did you live? Did you buy a home?
- dsnuh 8y agoSan Diego, and yes, bought a home in 2006 (smart move!) before we got married. The mortgage, deed, title, everything was in my name only, as my ex-wife (girlfriend at the time) had shitty credit, and zero savings. The house was deeply underwater the entire marriage, up until we split in 2016, when it would maaaaybe break even money if I sold it. I was renting a tiny studio apartment at the time, while still paying the mortgage, plus child and spousal support. I decided to try to stay in the house, since I didn't have the $3000-$5000 it takes for security deposits to rent, and I was hoping that if I could hold onto it, the value would increase to a point where I might come out with some money. I can't afford it at all, but so far I have been able to piece together payments before going into foreclosure, so I guess that's a win. The thing about divorce that I didn't realize is that making the decision to get divorced in the first place is the easiest and least painful of many choices you will need to make as a result.
- asdfman123 8y agoHow does that math work out? Why didn't you get at least half of it? Did you get full ownership of the house or something?
- 8y ago
- 40acres 8y agoI think you're right. About half my social circle is friends from work (other millennial in the high tech sector) and for the most part they are doing fine. Took a few years to knock out student loans but folks are saving well and buying houses now. The other half are those who had other degrees / no college and probably don't have a job that provides a 401k and I wouldn't be surprised if a majority don't know what an IRA is. Me and my long time girl friend have been really fortunate, no student loans and high paying jobs for the first 5 years out college. Our retirement portfolios are in a pretty good place right now. Seems that at all levels of American society inequality is rampant.
- asdfman123 8y ago> I can't imagine who these millennials are that have so much in a retirement account — presumably they also live in expensive areas if they are able to earn so much? Keep in mind ridiculous house prices are only in a handful of cities. The rest of the country exists and is doing just fine, thank you very much. I live in Houston and made $75k right out of school as an IT consultant. I lived in the cheapest apartment I could find in my favorite Houston neighborhood -- a place with a lot of art and nightlife. Despite it being a happening place, it only cost $700/mo in 2012. I was a big fan of the finance blogger Mr. Money Mustache and lived cheaply, on about $30k/yr. The rest of my salary went towards paying off my relatively low school debt, then I funneled it all to my Roth IRA, 401(k), and ESPP. After maxing that out, I bought taxable investments too. My goal was to retire in my mid-30s after making an average developer salary. From 2012-2015, my net worth went from -$30k to $150k. It's still rising, but not as quickly because my fiance doesn't have the same crazy ideas about money that I do. I bought a 3-bedroom townhouse in a nice neighborhood right near downtown. I can easily afford it and I'm not even making 6 figures yet.
- gnicholas 8y agoGood reminder about home prices around the country — my perspective is certainly skewed by my background in biglaw, where top salaries only exist in expensive markets. In tech, things are different — especially for those who can work remotely.
- collyw 8y agoNot sure about the US but in Europe most of the cities where good jobs are have daft house prices.
- claydavisss 8y agoThey may also have employers that match generously, probably uncool companies that actually have to pay people to compensate for their relative lack of hipness. 1:1 matching is almost unheard of now but was normal twenty years ago. Contemporary jobs provide for "unlimited" (translation: uncompensated) vacation time...no 401k matching...sometimes even a huge copay for health insurance.
- usingthistwice 8y agoI'm probably pretty unusual, but I'm 25, living in a high cost of living city (Boston), and have right around 200k saved right now between retirement and taxable accounts. Started at -15k out of college. High salaries around here definitely help, as does being relatively careful with money (though I don't limit myself much). I do plan to buy a house in 5-10 years, most likely in a lower cost of living area, ideally in cash.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoSo over 85% of millenials saved less than $20,000 for retirement?
- eximius 8y agoThe average/median salary for millenials is between $25-40k (the statistics I see vary significantly). I imagine that this article is basically a proxy for the poor wages millenials typically have. I'm a young millenial in a low cost city in Texas with a retirement account balance over the average by quite a bit. If you have the money to max your accounts every year, its very easy. And I've already bought and sold a house while I maxed out my accounts.
- gnicholas 8y agoIt's interesting to see how folks can live in other areas. Because retirement accounts have so many restrictions, people who anticipate spending $1M-$2M on a house in the next 10 years pretty much ignore them. Of course, these homes (at least ones near Palo Alto) are themselves a good investment, and carry tax benefits similar to (but smaller than) retirement accounts. Hearing the stories here makes me want to leave!
- zebrafish 8y agoNot necessarily. Those statistics would imply that there is a huge number with little to no savings at all which is what the article speaks to. Medians will move towards zero more quickly than means when as more zeros are added to the data set. A 32 year old has been working for about 10 years. S&P500 has been growing at 10.5% with dividends reinvested for the last 10 years. That means about $3500/yr in 401k contributions would get you to the average account balance. Take into account employer matches and that's honestly not as much as you expect it to be. Traditional wisdom is to put away 10% and employers have started to implement the auto-incrementing auto-enrollment features into their 401k plans that Richard Thaler has been promoting for the last several years.
- gnicholas 8y agoAll good points. My only comment would be that the average age of the people in the study was not 32. That was the maximum age.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- saltcured 8y agoMy wife's situation may serve as a useful example. She started with her current university employer about 3.5 years ago. In that time, her balance there has grown from zero to about $90k. This is from 401a/403b contributions and employer-matching based on a $125-150k salary and substantial market gains. She even used one of the Vanguard retirement funds targeted at millenial investors. We're actually gen x and have other retirement assets I'm ignoring here. But, this account illustrates real world performance that any number of tech workers could have reproduced in the same short time period. Not only that, but many are at an age where they could have been making contributions for 10-15 years now, rather than just 3-4...
- throwaway_goog 8y agoRoughly $700K between my wife (ex-bond-trader) and me. We are a couple years past 32 but had about $600K then, at which age I'd already quit my Google job and she'd quit her finance job.
- segmondy 8y agoI had saved up $100k at 23yrs old while living and working in Detroit and I started working at 19yrs old. Tons of folks in SF today with over a million saved at 32yrs old.
- bad_news_bears 8y agoI turn 25 in several weeks and my net worth just crossed $150k a month back. I currently make just shy of $80k in Minneapolis. The biggest recommendations I can give for trying to save more money: Make yourself work a bit – sock away more than what you would deem “comfortable” and live off the rest. You’ll be forced to really think about what’s worth spending on. Get a roommate. I save probably $3,000 a year from this alone, and a big plus is that I get along just fine with him. Spend frivolously on things that really let you have fun or relax – to a point. I like Mexican food, a good gym membership, and quality groceries. I don’t worry about what I spent on these items because I spend next-to-nothing elsewhere. Start young. I opened my Roth when I was 17 and have maxed it out each year, in addition to maxing our my work retirement accounts the last few years.