3 ms·
> Induction is invalid Can you rephrase this without using the word "induction"? Since that word seems to be confusing a lot of people in this discussion. My
by pdonis 8y ago
> Induction is invalid
Can you rephrase this without using the word "induction"? Since that word seems to be confusing a lot of people in this discussion.
My attempt at rephrasing, based on what it seems like you are using "induction" to mean, would be: it is always invalid to reason that the future will be exactly like the past. Or perhaps: it is always invalid to reason that our future data will show exactly the same patterns as our past data.
If this is what you are using "induction" to mean, then of course you are correct; but I don't think this is what others in this discussion are using "induction" to mean.
- lisper 8y agoGood grief, doesn't anyone on HN understand context any more? The top-level post here is "The new riddle of INDUCTION". When I use the word "induction" I mean what it means in the title, which is explained at great length in the paper. I mean this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning Not this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction
- sonusario 8y agoDoes explanatory theory make use of observation? Because based on the the wiki page for inductive reasoning, if you use observations for evidence, then you are using inductive reasoning to some capacity.
- lisper 8y agoWell, what I really mean by "induction" is what it means in the paper pointed to by the OP, i.e. the paper entitled "The new riddle of induction." I pointed to the wikipedia article just to contrast that with mathematical induction, which is NOT what I or anyone else is talking about here. Yes, explanatory theories rely on observations. But they are not just straightforward extrapolations of the form, "Because we have observed something N times (e.g. we have seen N green emeralds) we can reliably conclude that we will continue to observe it (e.g. all emeralds are green)."
- sonusario 8y ago> Yes, explanatory theories rely on observations. But they are not just straightforward extrapolations of the form, "Because we have observed something N times (e.g. we have seen N green emeralds) we can reliably conclude that we will continue to observe it (e.g. all emeralds are green)." Interesting. I will need to look further into explanatory theories, because my current understanding tells me that anything that uses observational evidence is inductive (even without following the "observed something N times" form).
- lisper 8y agoYou can choose to lump Popperian epistemology (what I have been calling "explanatory theories") together with other kinds of inductive reasoning, but that misses the point. If you cast your linguistic net wide enough, then there are a lot of different kinds of inductive reasoning. But only one of them actually works, and it's not the one that Goodman uses. At that point calling them both "inductive" robs the word of its utility.
- pdonis 8y ago> I mean this How does what the Wikipedia article is describing differ from what you are calling "explanatory"? As far as I can tell, the reasoning used to build scientific models, for example, falls within what is described as "inductive" reasoning in the article (the article's description is very general, leaving room for lots of different kinds of inductive reasoning); but you are saying scientific models aren't built using inductive reasoning but are "explanatory". Is there a one or two sentence description of the difference? Or are we all forced to buy and read Deutsch's book?
- lisper 8y agoExplaining what an explanatory theory is won't fit in an HN comment. I'll have to refer you to David Deutsch [1] (or Karl Popper) for that. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Fabric-Reality-Parallel-Universes-Implications/dp/014027541X https://www.amazon.com/Fabric-Reality-Parallel-Universes-Imp...