8 ms·
The IRS has actually run trials like this in the past. Very successful, at least for simply W2-based returns, since most people's taxable transactions get repor
by gamblor956 8y ago
The IRS has actually run trials like this in the past. Very successful, at least for simply W2-based returns, since most people's taxable transactions get reported by companies anyway (i.e., mortgages/interest, other income, etc.) and most people use the standardized deduction.
Inuit and Quicken subsequently lobbied to end those programs and even bar the IRS from running similar programs...
- Someguywhatever 8y ago>Inuit and Quicken subsequently lobbied to end those programs and even bar the IRS from running similar programs... They did the same thing in Canada too btw.
- el_benhameen 8y agoWhile I'm sure that most tax prep companies have lobbied similarly, this is why I don't use TurboTax and other Intuit products.
- curiousgeorgio 8y agoNearly everyone I've talked to (on both sides of the political spectrum) agrees on this issue; if the IRS has the means to verify and audit the data, they might as well prepare the forms and just get authorization (+ any additional info they might be lacking) before tax returns are submitted. So how is it that lobbying alone is enough to persuade lawmakers to take the side of Intuit et al.? And which lawmakers are so easily "bought" at the detriment of the public? I'm just as pessimistic as anyone when it comes to the corruption of our government, but this seems like a pretty black and white issue. There must be more to it...
- MaysonL 8y agoLobbying + campaign contributions. + the knowledge that as long as they don't change the situation, they'll be able to expect future campaign contributions.
- curiousgeorgio 8y agoI agree that may be a factor in more controversial issues where siding with lobbyists doesn't come at the cost of alienating a huge majority of your constituents. This seems different. Almost everyone (from what I understand) agrees, so it's a pretty clear case where we should be able to call out those lawmakers and say "you're obviously only doing this for the money/job security - you can't even pretend to be against it on principle."
- kmkemp 8y agoThere are many issues that are in similar spots. The go to strategy to deal with those has been to either: (1) ignore it completely if it's not getting sufficient media coverage to cause outrage or (2) control the coverage by making it seem as if the public is divided, typically using various forms of poor (but effective) arguments, statistically invalid polling, and research that only gets published if it produces the desired result I'd say this falls into the first category.
- wpietri 8y agoThe preference of average citizens appears to be almost immaterial to what Congress actually does. Instead, interest groups and rich people are the ones who win. E.g.: https://www.vox.com/2014/4/18/5624310/martin-gilens-testing-theories-of-american-politics-explained https://www.vox.com/2014/4/18/5624310/martin-gilens-testing-...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> So how is it that lobbying alone is enough to persuade lawmakers to take the side of Intuit et al.? The lobbying is a big part, but the other part is anti-tax ideologues in Congress want to keep the tax process as painful as possible so that people are as angry as possible about taxes, to maximize support for and engagement on anti-tax policies.
- Symmetry 8y agoThere are also 1.2 million tax preparers in the US. I'm not going to vote for somebody who has the wrong opinion on, e.g., abortion just because they're going to make my taxes easier but if the change to taxes was going to eliminate my job I'd feel differently. Also, the complex nature of the US tax code means that the people who've put effort into gaming the system and the dishonest also stand to lose if move to a more reasonable system. So it's really not just about the campaign contributions but actual substantial interest groups.
- jriot 8y agoYou can't have a right or wrong opinion, its just an opinion.
- mrunkel 8y agoOf course you can. It's a matter of perspective. From your viewpoint, someone else that has an opposing opinion has the "wrong" opinion. That's what GP was saying. Maybe it would have been clearer if they said "position" instead?
- jriot 8y agoIt appears your opinion on the matter is wrong.
- maxerickson 8y agoIt's just a manner of expression, they simply mean someone they disagree with.
- arebop 8y agoMaybe lobbying and the current rules about campaign finance are undemocratic and should be changed, but meantime where's the lobbying group where we can donate to advocate for tax simplification? I used to think it was Americans for Tax Reform, now I think Tax Policy Center is the closest thing, but while Bankman has worked a lot with them in the past, in this article they seem at least ambivalent if not opposed to it. Any other suggestions of which nonprofit lobbying organizations can be used to offset the impact of Americans for Tax Reform, Intuit, and other organizations who favor tax complexification?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Camillo 8y agoIf a policy would bring a small benefit to a large number of people, but a large loss to a small number, the small group is much more motivated to fight against the policy, and will often win. This is why it is generally not possible to abolish special programs, shrink the size of the government, etc. Also note that the "pure flat tax" idea earlier in this discussion and the "universal basic income" idea discussed elsewhere on this website have the same problem: the promised simplification comes from eliminating a bunch of special programs, exemptions, benefits etc., which is impossible.
- paulcole 8y ago> Inuit and Quicken subsequently lobbied to end those programs and even bar the IRS from running similar programs... Is this true or an urban legend?
- kalleboo 8y agohttps://www.propublica.org/article/filing-taxes-could-be-free-simple-hr-block-intuit-lobbying-against-it https://www.propublica.org/article/filing-taxes-could-be-fre...
- paulcole 8y agoHow do you tell which bills were targeted with their lobbying dollars? In 2016 Intuit's revenue was something like $4.7 billion. And they spent $2 million lobbying against bills that threaten the fundamental nature of their business? That seems absurdly low to me.
- ben_w 8y agoWhy overspend if you don’t need to?
- nimish 8y agoIt turns out buying votes in Congress is actually quite cheap.
- kalleboo 8y ago> How do you tell which bills were targeted with their lobbying dollars? It looks like this information is published by the senate under the "Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995" https://soprweb.senate.gov/index.cfm?event=getFilingDetails&filingID=04898617-5304-4EE0-BF55-78A8EA285D46&filingTypeID=60 https://soprweb.senate.gov/index.cfm?event=getFilingDetails&... opensecrets.org has a more easily-browsed index linking to the senate reports: https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000022016 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000022016
- devhead 8y ago
- dcosson 8y agoThere was an interesting Planet Money episode about this [0]. Apparently the lobbying by Intuit is actually fairly minor compared to the opposition by Republicans. Some group of Republican legislators came together and agreed to oppose all tax increases, and also agreed to oppose many types of tax simplification. The thinking being that the more painful filing your taxes is, the more people will have a negative perception of taxes in general and be opposed to tax increases. [0] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/03/22/521132960/episode-760-tax-hero https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/03/22/521132960/epis...
- philwelch 8y agoMost Republican "flat tax" ideas have tax simplification as a major selling point (e.g. Ted Cruz talking about filing your taxes on a postcard); if you can simplify the implementation of the existing tax schedule, you lose that selling point.
- maxxxxx 8y agoFlat tax doesn't even simplify anything. The problem with taxes is to determine what the taxable income is. Figuring out the tax rate is trivial once you have that, no matter what the curve is. Flat tax is just another attempt to give big tax breaks to higher incomes.
- philwelch 8y agoThat's true. I never said the Ted Cruz postcard gimmick was honest; if it was honest, then it couldn't be sabotaged by simplifying the taxpayer experience for the existing schedule of rates and deductions.
- avar 8y ago> Flat tax doesn't even simplify anything. Yes it does, depending on the implementation. There's a 2005 Economist article which does a good job of summarizing why[1]. BEGIN QUOTE Fewer brackets are simpler to administer, but one bracket is simplest of all. Under a pure flat tax, the taxman takes the same cut from the last dollar you earn that he took from the first. The appeal to high earners is obvious. But the administrative elegance of such a system is not so immediately apparent. Because every dollar is taxed at the same rate, it does not matter to the tax collector how many dollars are going to whom. Thus, in principle, the taxman could simply withhold 20% of a company's payroll, without needing to know who was paid what. Add a second rate of tax, however, or a personal exemption, and the tax collector must find out how much money is going into each pay packet before he can be sure of collecting the right amount from the right person. In America, for example, the tax collector needs to tax the wage packets of 130m or more employees, rather than simply taxing the payrolls of 8m or so enterprises. END QUOTE The mistake you're making is assuming that the tax system can only be simplified on the individual level, but as the quote above demonstrates this isn't true. Certain changes to the tax code do entirely away with the need for the government to exhaustively audit large parts of the economy. Another quote from the article demonstrating such a case: BEGIN QUOTE In Canada, Australia and the European Union, for example, staple foods, but not restaurant meals, are exempted from value-added tax. [Therefore] hot roast chicken is taxed, but cold roast chicken is not. “Does anyone expect tax administrators and business owners to have thermometers on hand when they do their tax calculations?” END QUOTE In this example, by progressively taxing food you're creating the accounting problem that the government theoretically has to track economic activity down to the level of whether a chicken was warm or not when it was sold. Simplifying the tax code does away with needing to solve that problem entirely, and eliminates some of the current incentives for tax avoidance and other fraud. 1. https://www.economist.com/special-report/2005/04/14/the-case-for-flat-taxes https://www.economist.com/special-report/2005/04/14/the-case...
- rayiner 8y agoFun fact. Intuit spent just $2.4 million on lobbying per year and $775,000 on campaign contributions: https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000026667&cycle=2016 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000026667&c.... If their lobbying dollars are what caused the IRS to stop those programs, you could "outbid" them with just a Kickstarter. Intuit and friends are a red herring: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/grover-norquist/grover-norquist-taxes_b_3005698.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/grover-norquist/grover-norqui...
- sjm-lbm 8y agoI've been told by people that have been involved with lobbying that it's way cheaper than you'd expect. Almost a million in the right congressional races can buy you a lot of stalling in congress. Also, IMHO, few people have messed up US tax policy like Grover Norquist. Even if you don't agree with that particular humble opinion, he is, at the very least, a figure with his own agenda to push. He's far from an unbiased source.
- fencepost 8y agoI've been told by people that have been involved with lobbying that it's way cheaper than you'd expect. Almost a million in the right congressional races can buy you a lot of stalling in congress. My take on this remains what it's been for decades (offensive words, but I'm not sure what would fit better) : "I'm not surprised that politicians are whores. I'm horribly disappointed that they're cheap sleazy whores."
- tptacek 8y agoA million dollars can be an entire Congressional race in most of the country.
- dangjc 8y agoThey are not a red herring. California tried to do this, and its a Democratic state, not swayed by Grover Norquist, but Intuit blocked it. https://www.npr.org/2017/03/29/521954033/stanford-professor-loses-political-battle-to-simplify-tax-filing-process https://www.npr.org/2017/03/29/521954033/stanford-professor-...