3 ms·
> we don't have a justification, other than induction Yes, we do. Scientific theories are justified by their explanatory power. Read Deutsch.
by lisper 8y ago
> we don't have a justification, other than induction
Yes, we do. Scientific theories are justified by their explanatory power. Read Deutsch.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoHow much of that explanatory power is derived from explaining things that have happened in the past, vs how much from explaining things that have happened in the future? You can fire a cannonball and observe a parabolic arc, you can learn to hit a target reliably from any distance, and you can develop a unified theory of gravity, air resistance, and the rotation of the earth that explains why firing at such-and-such angle with such-and-such amount of power will strike a target at a fixed location. That theory will allow you to hit targets reliably even in firing situations that you've never encountered in the past. But induction is your only justification for believing that gravity, air resistance, and the rotation of the earth will affect cannonballs and missiles the same way tomorrow as they did yesterday.
- lisper 8y ago> you can learn to hit a target reliably from any distance Not without developing an explanatory theory you can't. Read Deutsch.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Not without developing an explanatory theory you can't. This is absolutely false as a matter of historical fact; the theory always follows a period of trial-and-error in which you learn how to hit the target by raw experimentation. There's a pretty simple reason for this, which is that the trial-and-error approach is easy to execute. > Read Deutsch. Any reason I should do this? "Read Deutsch" isn't exactly a compelling argument against the idea that theories derive their authority from a track record of success, as opposed to something more non-inductive such as divine ordination.
- lisper 8y ago> This is absolutely false as a matter of historical fact; No, it isn't. > the theory always follows a period of trial-and-error That is true. > in which you learn how to hit the target by raw experimentation. No, that is not true. In order to hit the target you have to extrapolate the results of your raw experimentation somehow, because you can never completely reproduce the circumstances of any experiment. If you try to do that extrapolation using induction, you will succeed with odds no greater than chance. > Any reason I should do this? Because if you're going to dispute someone's position, you really ought to first inform yourself what that position actually is rather than argue against a straw man.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoIf the only thing you have to say about your position is "I'm not going to bother to go into it. Read Deutsch", I don't imagine you'll persuade many people that there's anything worthwhile they'd get out of Deutsch.
- lisper 8y agoI'm sorry, but there are some things worth knowing that simply cannot be distilled down to pithy slogans, and if you want to understand them you are going to have to do some work. If you're not willing to do that, well, that is really no concern of mine.