5 ms·
Induction [1] is logically invalid, full stop. It was thoroughly debunked by Karl Popper, whose theory was popularized by David Deutsch in his book, "The Fabri
by lisper 8y ago
Induction [1] is logically invalid, full stop. It was thoroughly debunked by Karl Popper, whose theory was popularized by David Deutsch in his book, "The Fabric of Reality". The easiest way to see that induction is invalid is to observe that the sun has risen in the east every day for the last few billion years, but it is not valid to conclude that the sun will continue to rise in the east forever. (It won't.)
The grue/bleen riddle was also debunked by Deutsch with the pithy slogan, "Languages are theories." The words you use to describe your theory are not arbitrary. The concepts they stand for can themselves be judged in the same terms that the theory overall is judged by, namely, do they have explanatory power? "Green" and "blue" have explanatory power. They sum up complex physical processes in a very compact form. "Grue" and "bleen" do not. There are in fact blue and green things in the world, and physics can explain why there are blue and green things. But there are no grue or bleen things, and Goodman cannot justify why he wants to insert an arbitrary time parameter into his terminology. The grue/bleen theory can be rejected on those grounds alone.
There are some legitimately time-dependent terms in use, for example, "President of the United States", or "main-sequence star". But the time-dependence of both of those can be justified in terms of phenomena that actually occur in the world.
---
[1] Note that in the context of Goodman, this means logical induction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning), not mathematical induction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction). The former is invalid, the latter is not.
- sonusario 8y ago... but it is not valid to conclude that the sun will continue to rise in the east forever. (It won't.) Can you use induction in a valid way to invalidate induction?
- lisper 8y agoNo. Induction is invalid, full stop. It cannot be validly used to demonstrate anything.
- sonusario 8y agoThen how do you know that the sun won't rise forever?
- lisper 8y agoPhysics. In about 5 billion years the sun will become a red giant and destroy the earth. https://www.e-education.psu.edu/astro801/content/l6_p2.html https://www.e-education.psu.edu/astro801/content/l6_p2.html
- sonusario 8y agoSo induction was not used to determine this?
- lisper 8y agoNo.
- sonusario 8y agoThen what form of reasoning was used? You stated that we cannot validly claim that the sun will rise forever just because we've observed it rise in the east every day for the last few billion years. Then you cite stellar observations that we use to claim that the sun will become a red giant and destroy the earth. What are the differences in those observations that make one invalid induction and the other not?
- lisper 8y ago> stellar observations that we use to claim that the sun will become a red giant and destroy the earth No. We have never observed a star become a red giant. That process takes millions of years, and we have only been doing astronomy for a few hundred. The reason we know that the sun will become a red giant is not because we have ever observed this process happen, but because we have an explanatory theory of how stars work. Going into detail on how that process works is a little too long for an HN comment. If you really want to know, read David Deutsch's "The Fabric of Reality", particularly chapter 7. (Or go straight to the source and read Karl Popper.)
- jonbarker 8y agoNot sure, but I can use deduction: 1) If induction is valid, then it follows that we can use induction to reason about the world. 2) But we can't use it to reason about the world, 3) so it isn't valid. (Modus Tollens) This is valid, but not necessarily sound. Soundness implies that first two statements (premises) are also true. The second premise is clearly not true, because we use induction to reason all the time. So the conclusion #3, while it follows as a valid argument, cannot be said to be a 'sound conclusion.'
- lisper 8y ago> we use induction to reason all the time Yes, people use all kinds of invalid reasoning techniques and fall victim to a wide variety of logical fallacies and cognitive biases. That doesn't mean that any of them are valid.
- jonbarker 8y agoI think you are expecting the term 'validity' to mean more than what it technically means to people in philosophy, which is that it 'adheres to the form of either Modus Ponens or Modus Tollens'. Colloquially it has come to mean more like what soundness means, which is valid but also with true premises.
- lisper 8y agoI don't want to quibble over terminology. Inductive reasoning is wrong. Mistaken. Bogus. Intellectually bankrupt. Utterly without redeeming value of any kind. As likely to lead to correct conclusions as reading Tarot cards (which is to say, the probability is higher than 0, but not by a wide enough margin to have any utility).
- cube2222 8y agoWait, what? Do you mean induction in a specific case, or induction overall? Because your counterexample just isn't provable by induction. There's no inductive step there... There's no reason to believe that if the sun went up east on the n'th day it will do so on the n+1'th as well.
- lisper 8y agoI mean this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning which is what the OP is about. Totally different from this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction which is logically valid.
- cube2222 8y agoThanks you for the clarification! I've seen the OP, didn't understand it really though.
- pdog 8y agoMathematical induction is a logical method of proof. Don't confuse it with inductive reasoning.
- lisper 8y agoIn the context of a discussion of Goodman's "The New Riddle of Induction", the word "induction" means inductive reasoning. Mathematical induction is a completely different thing, notwithstanding that the same word is used to label it.
- bhritchie 8y agoThis argument, including the "will the sun rise tommorow" example, is these days most associated (at least in philosophy) with the 18th-century philosopher David Hume. See here for example: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/9662/9662-h/9662-h.htm#mnum21 http://www.gutenberg.org/files/9662/9662-h/9662-h.htm#mnum21