17 ms·
US elections remain 'dangerously vulnerable' to cyber-attacks
- MichaelApproved 8y agoIt's insane that we have systems using 100% electric vote counting. Any system, even 100% paper ballots, are hackable. They key is making the hack difficult to scale. Computer systems are easy to hack from a distance and in large numbers. Theoretically, one person could hack many devices from another country. Paper ballots require someone to change/stuff in person. One person can do limited damage and would have to be in the country. You'd need to recruit large numbers for an effective operation. Electric assistance is fine but ultimately you need a paper result that a human can read. A computer can help you make selections and fill out the ballot but the voter must be able to read the printed result and confirm their vote was properly printed. I'd be against any computer counting for the initial count. Manual is slower and expensive but it's worth the added cost to have a more secure voting system.
- antris 8y ago> A computer can help you make selections and fill out the ballot but the voter must be able to read the printed result and confirm their vote was properly printed. And that would essentially make the voting machine a very expensive pen.
- MichaelApproved 8y agoWhich is perfectly fine. Remember the hanging chad issue from 2000 presidential election? This expensive pen would eliminate that issue. Also, with clearly filled out ballots, manual counting would be more reliable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- umanwizard 8y agoFriendly reminder: electronic voting is totally unnecessary. Many highly developed democracies (e.g. France) have totally paper voting where the ballots never leave the public eye. If the past is any indication, there will almost certainly be a lot of comments on this article proposing complicated schemes for making electronic voting secure and verifiable. Consider when evaluating these schemes whether there is any benefit or upside at all over good old fashioned unhackable paper.
- liberte82 8y agoThe best benefit I've heard about paper voting is the mechanism by which trust in the count is ensured. With paper voting, all votes are counted by several people, with oversight and random recounts. It is _possible_ to cheat, but it would require a local conspiracy for a limited number of votes. With electronic voting, the counting is done by machines and the mechanism is obfuscated and unverifiable. If it's working correctly, it should be perfect; but if the machines were hacked, it could be done through a network and the impacts could be massive. It would require a large conspiracy to pull off, but the number of votes that could be affected could change an election. So in summary: paper voting = higher chance of small irregularities, with limited impact; electronic voting = lower chance of massive irregularities with election changing consequences. In paper voting, the trust is distributed, while in electronic voting, it is centralized.
- florabuzzword 8y agoOverall, well put, and those points are tough to discount. > With electronic voting, the counting is done by machines and the mechanism is obfuscated and unverifiable. Could a blockchain not address that with public/private keys? Why is this ridiculous?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xori 8y agoBecause your vote also needs to be private to the point where a third-party can't verify that a vote belongs to you. To prevent selling of votes, or forced votes via blackmail.
- empath75 8y agoI think we’re going to find out that election machines have been regularly hacked since they were first released and that they were in fact designed to be insecure. It’s been well known that they were broken and unauditable going back to the Black Box Voting days of 2004 when everyone thought Bev Harris was some kind of paranoid nut job.
- liberte82 8y agoFormer CEO of Diebold, in 2003 when the first electronic voting machines were used (back when it was controversial, and people hadn't given in to this idea that it is inevitable and inherently "better" than paper voting): "I am committed to helping Ohio deliver its electoral votes to the president."
- kryogen1c 8y ago>Donald Trump publicly invited Russia to hack Hillary Clinton’s email server I find statements like this to be immediately discrediting of journalistic integrity. The intent was not to enter into an illicit agreement with a third party. Reacting in this ridiculous fashion only aids in his popularity. I think Democrat (obviously false) hyperbole is in danger of giving us a second term
- swarnie_ 8y agoIts The Guardian, they are about as far removed from Trump and his base as its possible to be. Not that i approve of what their doing here, just explaining the motivation.
- kryogen1c 8y agoThat's kinda my point. They're discrediting Trump in the most credit-giving way possible and minimizing their following while maximizing his. there are so many legitimate issues to try and take a win on, but they do childish things like this instead. Definitely heading towards a republican in 2020 at this rate.
- siosonel 8y agoTo me, it's definitely not the "most credit-giving way" or the "most childish thing". The Russia angle is a really big deal, it goes to the core of the legitimacy of Trump's presidency. Not only that, it demonstrates the direction his authoritarian tendencies is likely to lead the country into, with his open admiration of strongmen and inexplicable questioning of the historic goodwill within the NATO alliance. His guilt over Russia involvement can be inferred by his constant obsession and attempts to discredit typical law enforcement investigation practices. It is a big deal to have a sitting president acting similar to how a guilty defendant would with (1) a video inviting computer hacking, (2) documented lies or rewrites of "official" statements about a Trump tower meeting of senior Trump campaign officials with the representatives of the invitees, (3) an announcement of an upcoming press briefing about contents (emails) of the hacking target made at the time of the meeting, (4) news reports of surveilled increase in hacker activities at the time of the hacking invite. All of the above are not credit-giving or childish. At the same time, an alternative of explaining government policies and trade numbers would likely not get through the electorate, and in my opinion unlikely to change hardened or media-saturated minds.
- brbrodude 8y agoKarma
- MichaelApproved 8y agoThis numberphile video does a good job explaining why electric voting is a terrible idea. https://youtu.be/w3_0x6oaDmI https://youtu.be/w3_0x6oaDmI
- davidw 8y agoWorth repeating: Senator Ron Wyden has a bill that would require paper ballots. Worth calling your lawmakers to support. Edit: press release with link to the full text of the bill - https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-gillibrand-markey-merkley-murray-and-warren-introduce-bill-to-secure-elections- https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-gilli...
- beat 8y agoI would love to see Democrats pick up a blanket ban on paperless electronic voting as an issue. The GOP won't, for, um, reasons. This is a marvelous partisan opportunity, if the Democrats are wise enough to pick it up.
- komali2 8y agoRepublicans won't for the very simple reason that it's supported by democrats. The Republican party made it abundantly clear for the last decade that their primary platform is "don't let the left have any wins."
- jumelles 8y agoParty over country.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoThe Democrats also would never go through with this. The Democrats are Establishment Elite who have everything absolutely perfect right now except for a little push from the far left that they're trying to crush. Get this idea out of your head that the Democrats in the current form even give the slightest of shit about American's ability to vote safely & securely unless it has something do with Russia.
- beat 8y agoWhen you say "The Democrats", who are you talking about, exactly? Because I'm pretty sure every rank and file Democrat I know would agree with me on this issue.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Mbioguy 8y agoDoesn't going paper-only make it difficult to switch to alternative voting systems like RCV (as Maine is) or multiple-member districting at anything beyond a local level? FPTP is fairly simple to count by hand and other methods can be more labor-intensive as the total number of votes increases. I am all for having a paper trail, mandatory audits, and secure infrastructure. I agree with those who thing the current private sector systems for voting have huge issues. What I don't understand is what I see as media pushing a false choice between paper or digital. Estonia has been using e-voting alongside paper ballots for years without serious issues. (Of course, they have national ID and have digitized a lot of their gov't functions, so maybe this is a special case.) https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/12/18/estonia-the-digital-republic https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/12/18/estonia-the-di... There are a lot of ways to improve our elections, from social engineering (France's media blackout a few days before elections, moving voting day to the weekend, making it multiple days, or just using the mail system) to improved systems like Scantegrity or increased use of optical scanning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity The cynic in me fears this is a push designed to make it harder for us to use things like RCV and entrench FPTP.
- ska 8y agoI don't see why paper makes different systems more difficult. Paper is more about how votes are registered and counted, voting systems are more about how they are aggregated and decided. Re: your comment on social engineering, etc. There has been a ton of effort in arenas in the US electoral system(s), but the goals have not been security or access - sometimes quite the opposite.
- Mbioguy 8y agoI was part of a now-tabled push for RCV in a red state a few years back. While it offered a solution to several issues and had some multiparty support, the big problem arose when the state legislators realized that the current machines used to aid in tabulating and reporting results couldn't do RCV tabulation. This meant either new machines would need to be bought or it would all have to be done by hand. The clerks ran the numbers and the number of volunteers required or increased cost was not viable. The decision was made to table considering RCV use statewide until the machines were scheduled to be replaced in half a decade. The problem is that an individual ballot in RCV if counted manually, needs to be counted several times if the vote ends up switching to the 2nd, 3rd, or fourth choice etc. As the number of total votes increases from the thousands to hundreds of thousands (or even millions), this can cause a pseudo-exponential growth in the amount of counting labor performed. Large municipalities that have trialed RCV have forged ahead with manual counts and succeeded despite the increased effort, but it has sometimes taken days to report results. That's only after massive amounts of labor from volunteers. Going statewide with manual-only counts of paper ballots (no optical scanning or other machine-assisted counting) makes RCV or other methods of determining winner much more difficult because of the labor or cost involved. It should be clear that I quite like RCV, but this is a factor to consider.
- ciconia 8y agoI think there's a good chance the 2016 US elections were in fact manipulated, and the upcoming mid-terms are not gonna be any different. "[The hackers] wouldn’t need too heavy a hand... just a couple of tweaks here and there." [1] Sadly, it's in the interest of the ruling party to look the other way. [1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-russia-could-steal-the-midterms/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-russia-could-steal-...
- InternetPerson 8y agoA hostile nation targeted our elections in 2016. We know that much. In February, the NY Times writes, "The Justice Department charged 13 Russians and three companies on Friday in a sprawling indictment that unveiled a sophisticated network designed to subvert the 2016 election" [1] OK, so Russia had this expensive, sophisticated operation to influence the election. It wasn't a half-assed effort. So why wouldn't this operation include attacking voting machines? Especially if the machines are vulnerable and virtually unprotected? [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/16/us/politics/russians-indicted-mueller-election-interference.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/16/us/politics/russians-indi...
- SlowRobotAhead 8y ago>A hostile nation targeted our elections in 2016. We know that much. Are you talking about some entity releasing damaging emails and details from Clinton's campaign and the DNC that made Clinton look bad? Was the content of those messages not more important than how they were released? How does showing Clinton campaigns dirt related to voting machine hacking?
- mistermann 8y ago> A hostile nation targeted our elections in 2016. We know that much. I hope there can be some sort of a partial agreement that Noam Chomsky isn't a partisan hack, let's see what he has to say on the matter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vVXlLgifxQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vVXlLgifxQ I encourage everyone to watch the whole video, as there is some interesting (in that is it rather contradictory to the current mainstream narrative) footage of various Democrat opinions on Russia, and the degree to which they should be considered a threat to America. I feel fairly confident this footage predates "Deep Fakes" technology, if anyone suspects it isn't legit please let me know.
- beat 8y agoElectronic voting without paper trail should be illegal. Flat out. But it won't ever be so, which is curious.
- 40acres 8y agoCongress recently failed to pass a bill which would add election security funding, so we know where they stand.
- 0xfeba 8y agoBut VoterID!
- olivermarks 8y ago"It's not the people who vote that count, it's the people who count the votes."
- maxxxxx 8y agoConsidering how militant US politics is I wouldn't be too surprised if the people in power are actually OK with cyber-attacks as long as they go their way. Coming from Germany I don't even comprehend how the US is not able to run elections in a way that can be trusted. The 2000 Supreme Court decision should have been a big warning. I really believe there are a lot of people who don't want to fix the system because it would take away the opportunity to create more theater and conspiracy theories along party lines
- elif 8y agoAfter the 2000 (record speed) SC ruling, many people were vocal and protesting. Then that died out around September...
- maxxxxx 8y agoWhen Trump came out claiming that millions of illegal voters had voted there should have been a huge alarm and everybody should have worked on making sure there are no doubts. Instead it seems the partisans are perfectly fine with a lot of citizens not trusting the election system. This is a really dangerous game. Once people don't trust elections or the judiciary democracy is in grave danger.
- liberte82 8y agoWhy do you think Trump is continuously attacking the integrity of the very institutions that are meant to keep democracy intact? (the legislative bodies, the judiciary, and the fourth estate).
- marviel 8y agoCan anyone on HN provide me a good article or explanation as to why digital voting machines could be considered better for democracy? My intuitive reckoning is that making the "verifiability check" for a given vote something that non-technical people could carry out would increase the number of eyes on both sides which could point out inconsistencies. EDIT: added/removed words for clarity
- giarc 8y agoI don't have any articles, but I think I could come up with one reason why electronic voting may be preferred. The last time I voted was a municipal election in my city. I was given 3 separate ballots (mayor, my city councillor and my school board trustee). My understanding is that many elections in the states also have multiple propositions and other things the citizens are asked to vote on. So the paper system could become cumbersome and confusing with many issues on the ballot. Therefore, an electronic system where you are presented a single item at a time could be easier. I'd still argue that paper ballots are better for security issues, but the above could be one argument against paper ballots.
- gonmf 8y agoJust to add my 2 cents. I participated in elections before, both as a candidate and as member of the voting table (at instances at the same time as well). If there is some complicit agreement you can see certain leaning votes being discarded as not being clear enough, mostly because they are too left for the table or the inverse. This is widespread and a mostly unknown phenomena, since no one is going to recount a table for a small percentage of discrepancy. I don't know anything about electronic voting but if it can guarantee there is no personal opinion in the middle, good.