4 ms·
The article appears to describe only Google’s controls over your account, ignoring the iOS restrictions that allow iPhone and iPad users to prevent Google from
by macintux 8y ago
The article appears to describe only Google’s controls over your account, ignoring the iOS restrictions that allow iPhone and iPad users to prevent Google from seeing the data in the first place.
Unfortunate that they don’t make that clear.
- izacus 8y agoAnd exact same thing is true for Android as well - even Google apps won't get location data if you disable the permission or toggle.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoSo, you're saying one can allow some apps to have access to location data *andµ not allow Google from accessing it? Wow. Please tell me how to that. I've been trying to do that for yeaaaars (to no avail). I have a Moto G5 with Android 7.1. Please tell me.
- izacus 8y agoDepends on what do you mean by "not allowing Google from accessing it"? Setting location mode to GPS only and disabling Location permissions / Location History for Google apps in your app settings should probably do what you want.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y ago>disabling Location permissions / Location History for Google apps in your app settings should probably do what you want. Google services automatically re-enable these permissions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- repolfx 8y agoAndroid enforces permissions on Google apps too. I don't think that's what this is about. Rather, the AP is interpreting location history as a feature that controls all use of geographical location for any purpose across all products. But what it actually refers to is a specific product called literally Location History which lets you see where you've been on a timeline and map. The article does admit half way down that Google says this clearly in popups that appear when you toggle these settings on and off. So the "story" here is, if you want to call it a story, that some AP journalist and a couple of academics believe these warnings are not worded clearly enough. They may well have a point but I'm not sure this rises to the level of news. It'd also be very hard to really eliminate _all_ use of location across all products. Even very basic queries like [buy flowers] needs some rough idea of the user's location to give results that aren't nonsense. Even just opening Google Maps has to request the tiles for your current location, and as those tiles are customised to your prior usage of maps, who you are has to be sent along with the tile query. How do you implement that without Google knowing your rough location? The provider knowing this is rather inherent to the whole concept of digital maps to begin with. So I can't imagine Google offering the sort of setting the AP wants.
- frabcus 8y agoThe point is that it doesn't need to record that data. It doesn't give technical details, but the article seems to make it clear that it does record locations. If I just open Google Maps, I don't expect Google to permanently remember my location. I expect them to just serve the right map data anonymously.
- repolfx 8y agoAnd they'll do exactly that if you aren't logged in to an account. The AP story is arguing that you should be able to have a Google account, and have a setting that removes all uses of location data anywhere. Google don't offer that. They do offer anonymous access though. Perhaps the AP should just use that instead.
- Symbiote 8y ago