4 ms·
Template for discussion: A: It requires hypothetical exotic matter. It's just theoretical thought experiment. B: counterargument: The existence of exotic mat
by nabla9 8y ago
Template for discussion:
A: It requires hypothetical exotic matter. It's just theoretical thought experiment.
B: counterargument: The existence of exotic matter is not theoretically ruled out, so it could be real.
A: That's not a good argument. Something completely hypothetical invented so that it allows what you want to happen not ruled out is not good argument for relevance.
B: platitude counterargument: "If an elderly but distinguished scientist says that something is possible, he is almost certainly right; but if he says that it is impossible, he is very probably wrong." - Arthur C. Clarke. MOT.
- bvinc 8y agoI'm not a physicist, but my understanding is that exotic matter isn't strictly required. They say that because what's needed is a sort of negative energy/mass to cause an anti-gravity effect. But even that isn't accurate. What's really required is a lower energy density than a vacuum. This can be achieved in some cases, for example, in the casimir effect. When you look at it that way, it opens up some possibility, that we could achieve this in some sort if fashion, at least on a small scale, right? Can someone more knowledgeable than me weigh in on this?
- trhway 8y agothe best counterargument for me is that remote galaxies run away from us with the speeds larger than c. So space expansion and the speed faster than c as a result is possible. Without exotic matter, etc. Now there is just an engineering task of implementing it as a practical space ship drive. The arguments against FTL are based on fixed spacetime frames of references. Which is obviously not-applicable to the situation where the spacetime is what you actively manipulate. Spacetime manipulating approaches don't violate SR as nothing is moving faster than c wrt. local space. The same like with those remote galaxies - while running faster than c from us they don't move faster than c wrt. their local space.
- raattgift 8y ago> space expansion and the speed faster than c as a result is possible. Without exotic matter, etc. Except that in order to get the observables right, dark energy is required to keep the galaxy clusters running away from each other faster over time. It's a heavy price that no physical cosmologist is really happy about, but the concordance cosmology gets its name from how it is explicitly constructed to match ("concord with") observation (and it is consequently updated from time to time). It is not really surprising that some energy is required to keep the warp bubble from dissipating away from its compact region of spacetime, particularly since the Alcubierre model is a vacuum spacetime, so there's no mass in the middle to keep the bubble local to it (or source it, or however you want to look at it). He says so at the end of his paper[1]. It's important to remember that there is no observational evidence supporting Alcubierre's metric; it concords with nothing. However, one can still attempt to answer the questions he himself raised, and Lobo & Visser do just that in their 2004 paper[2], where they note that the geometry of the Alcubierre metric requires an even-more-unusual-than-dark-energy stabilizing term even at arbitrarily low warp-bubble velocities. - -- [1] https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/11/5/001 https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/11/5/001 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0009013 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0009013 (short, not especially difficult, fewer than 20 equations, 4 refs) See the text bracketing eqns (18) & (19) [2] https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/21/24/011 https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/21/24/011 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0406083 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0406083 (twice as long, but mostly developed through more than 120 equations, 38 refs incl. [1])
- draw_down 8y agoMy preferred rejoinder to crap like that is "A witty saying proves nothing - Voltaire"
- raattgift 8y agoAgreed. The pattern could range practically forever, with "B"s appearing for any "A": A: It's a static solution; the warp bubble is eternal. There is no recipe for turning it on or off. A: It's a vacuum solution; there is no "ship" inside, and no matter outside. It is everywhere exactly flat except for the compact region of spacetime in the bubble wall. The only way to decide whether it is even meaningfully moving in the sort of way intended is to add something else to the spacetime. One could make a more complicated vacuum solution with a qualitatively similar compact region, or "stitch" Alcubierre's solution into some other solution in a region where the latter is sufficiently flat to use an Israel-Darmois[1] approach, or add matter. A: Adding matter is hard. Practically anything either breaks the metric or alternatively requires releases from well-tested constraints on the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the stress-energy tensor. There is really no point in rehashing Lobo & Visser [2] here, although it would be a decent public service if a good science communicator explained its results. At least Alcubierre's original paper[3] is short and easily digestible. Everyone should read from the paragraph before eq. (18) to the paragraph following eq. (19). - -- Ultimately though "B"s are slogans, and matching them with pithier "A" slogans won't make "B"s go away (cf. young Earth creationists and anti-vaxxer). Perhaps it's more fruitful to make it easy for people caught in the middle to distinguish between a sloganeer with no idea of the content of the physical theories involved, and someone who at least knows the standard theory and how to use it before attempting to depart from it (thus excluding e.g. Sonny White). - -- [1] Misner, Thorne, & Wheeler, §21.13. [2] Lobo & Visser (!) https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/21/24/011 https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/21/24/011 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0406083 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0406083 [3] Alcubierre https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/11/5/001 https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/11/5/001 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0009013 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0009013