7 ms·
>Imagine the "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or car
by krapp 8y ago
>Imagine the "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or care about) the long-term consequences of that tinkering.
I once had, and never used, an idea that the consequence of using such technology was to accelerate dark energy, so that the more civilizations used FTL travel, the greater the energy requirements became. As if seafarers had to deal with the oceans expanding just a bit every time they were crossed.
- Razengan 8y ago> so that the more civilizations used FTL travel, the greater the energy requirements became. That sounds like a recipe for some terrible monopolization by the first few civilizations that manage to achieve FTL: Those who are the earliest to expand into the universe, would have access to the most resources, so they would be the only ones left who can afford to use FTL anymore, while younger civilizations may never have a chance to get out of their home stars.
- krapp 8y ago>That sounds like a recipe for some terrible monopolization by the first few civilizations that manage to achieve FTL: Yeah, that's where the "evil empire/East India Trading Company but in Spaaaaace" was going to come from. I wanted to use hyperspace/FTL as a vague metaphor for a scarce but crucial resource like fossil fuels (or whale oil, back in the day.)
- Razengan 8y ago> "evil empire/East India Trading Company but in Spaaaaace" I think it would be much more sinister. The FTL controllers would be seen as gods by species who have yet to leave their homeworld. Every civilization within their sphere of influence would be either have to be their allies, thralls, unable to move around in the galaxy unless they get piggyback rides by the FTL barons, or engulfed and extinguished by them. Imagine if we in the real world found out that there was no way to explore the universe we've been observing for centuries, unless we allied with some alien species that does not, can not, have our best interests on their minds. Interstellar travel would require resources, and resources would require interstellar travel.. To go against the FTL species you would need to control at least as many planets as they do, and to control that many planets you would need FTL travel.. Sounds like a monumentally hopeless reality.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Sounds like a monumentally hopeless reality. In terms of darkness and hopelessness, this is getting close to Cixin Liu's The Three-Body Problem trilogy. A rot13 spoiler follows. V xabj V fgvyy unir cnatf bs rkvfgragvny qernq nsgre gur frpbaq be guveq obbx vagebqhprq gur pbaprcg bs qvzrafvbany erqhpgvba jrncbaf. Onfvpnyyl, n fhcrejrncba gung fgnegf n furrg bs 2Q fcnpr rkcnaqvat ng yvtug fcrrq, juvpu erqhprf rirelguvat vg gbhpurf, vapyhqvat fcnpr vgfrys, gb 2Q. Vg'f bar bs znal JZQf ninvynoyr gb cbjreshy fcrpvrf. Abj gur qnex guvat vf, vg pna'g or fgbccrq. Bapr hayrnfurq, vg'yy xrrc rkcnaqvat ng yvtugfcrrq, qr-qvzrafvbavat fcnpr sberire. Ohg fcrrq bs yvtug vf fb fybj, gung lbh pna qebc vg ng lbhe rarzl'f ubzr flfgrz naq abg pner nobhg vg sbe zvyyravnf. Nsgre gung, sbyybjf gur dhrfgvba. Unir lbh rire jbaqrerq jul jr yvir va 3Q fcnpr naq abg, fnl, 12Q? Gung'f jul.
- Daneel_ 8y agoNice use of rot13.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWhy thank you. It's common elsewhere in places that don't have rich comment markup supporting spoiler tags; it dawned on me recently that I didn't see it used much on HN for some reason.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 8y agoDecoding it to ROT18 makes some amusing changes to the numbers. I think I have kinda grown out of such existential dread, once I started having a sort of intuition that the Universe is too inconceivably large to be uniformly altered, let alone "damaged", by any single event or entity (which also makes me cringe at sci-fi which throws the word "universe" around so lightly.) More importantly, I started thinking of the "backdrop" of Reality itself to not be Nothingness, but Everythingness. That is, the blackness we see out there, must not be the default state. I imagine a flood of "white" behind the void, and the reality we perceive is just a heavily-filtered slice of it. What led me to this way of looking at things was a comment on HN or Reddit, that talked about how, in certain axioms of mathematics, you can have a null/empty set but it's impossible to have a set which contains everything including itself. Whereas in another group of rules, it's impossible to have an empty set because everything else is arrived at by "subtracting" from the "infinite" set! Maybe someone here knows better of what I'm referring to.
- dogma1138 8y agoThat also sounds like a recipe for maintaining causality as in the faster you are trying to go to more you’ll expand space time maintaining the luminal speed limit from the point of view of an observer.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Those who are the earliest to expand into the universe, would have access to the most resources Eons ago, the universe was room temperature. I've always wondered how an intelligent species adapted to that time would perceive our universe.
- cgriswald 8y agoLikely, he wouldn't. The window in which the universe was roughly room temperature is very narrow in astronomical terms, so even if life did form during that period, it probably would not have been able to form even animal life, much less intelligent life.
- Razengan 8y agoIf everything was happening faster back then, and if we assume there were more interactions between everything and more kinds of interactions back then, then life and intelligence may have evolved faster too.
- cgriswald 8y agoThere's no reason to expect more kinds of interactions; the laws of physics were the same then as they are now. It also isn't clear that there would be more interactions. Galaxies hadn't formed, even if we stipulate that stars could have. So, the good: wherever a planet forms it should be warm enough for life (although it could still be too warm if it's close to its parent star). The bad: There are probably far fewer planets and ingredients for life and there is precious little time. For reference, for intelligent life to form during this period, it would have had to have done so at a rate of about 500:1 compared to the evolution of homo sapiens on Earth. Even life evolving in this narrow window would be difficult (~50:1 compared to on Earth).
- Zanni 8y agoYou might enjoy John Scalzi's latest, The Collapsing Empire. Not quite the same, but it does feature fast "currents" in spacetime that are in the process of "drying up," leaving distant systems stranded by uncrossable gulfs.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI've read a scifi story with this exact plot, so it looks like you're not alone!
- macintux 8y agoYeah, it's driving me crazy that I can't remember the author or title. As I recall there are some older species desperately trying to keep younger worlds from using the technology because the problem is going to keep getting worse.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI want to say it's a Ted Chiang story, but I'm not sure why - probably because his is the last collection of short stories I recall reading - but none of the titles listed look familiar.
- macintux 8y agoI don’t think so; as far as I know, I’ve only read his story that was adapted for Arrival.
- naravara 8y ago>I once had, and never used, an idea that the consequence of using such technology was to accelerate dark energy, so that the more civilizations used FTL travel, the greater the energy requirements became. As if seafarers had to deal with the oceans expanding just a bit every time they were crossed. I believe one of the aborted ending ideas (and dangling plot-threads) for the Mass Effect series was something like this. Like use of "Element Zero" (the exotic matter unobtanium that powers everything, including FTL travel) releases some kind of "dark energy" that is bad for vaguely defined reasons; one of which being that it destabilizes stellar fusion and makes stars go nova prematurely. So the "Reapers," or big-bads of the series, were an ancient civilization that set up a recurrent process of culling nascent advanced civilizations to prevent them from growing and using such technology to problematic levels. They ultimately scrapped it and went with an "AI and Man can't coexist" angle instead.
- Razengan 8y agoStar Control II, one of the inspirations for Mass Effect, also had some very interesting cosmic-scale intrigue, between many different species interacting over eons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Control_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Control_II