3 ms·
> mainstream nutrition science was a key contributor to American obesity crisis This seems unlikely given that mainstream nutrition science is the same in most
by nicoburns 8y ago
> mainstream nutrition science was a key contributor to American obesity crisis
This seems unlikely given that mainstream nutrition science is the same in most of the western world, but the obesity levels are far more severe in the US. From what I hear from friends who have travelled to the US (from the UK), standard portion sizes can be over twice as over on your side of the pond. And it can be very difficult to travel anywhere without a car. Seems to me this might have the bigger effect.
That said nutrition science really is a mess. Hopefully we'll work it out one day :)
- scottLobster 8y agoI think the issue stems from a holdover great depression mentality. Growing up I was taught to "clean my plate" and disciplined when I failed to do so, as wasting even a small amount of food was apparently some sort of cardinal sin despite my family being quite well off. I was also taught that eating large portions was a sign of health, an "active metabolism" (whatever the hell that is). Whenever I said I was done people would ask me if I was sure and offer me more. I was educated enough to figure things out in adulthood, but you raise a poorly educated populace on that mentality while making the least healthy food cheap and delicious, and shocker we have an obesity epidemic. :P
- robmaister 8y agoThat's certainly part of it, but I also think part of it is due to the economics of running a restaurant. Margins are getting thinner and thinner as people don't want to pay more for the same food (despite this being how inflation works), so one strategy is to charge more and offer larger portions. The cost of a larger portion is minimal relative to the higher price (especially in dishes that are made in large batches anyways). So the restaurant is happy to be getting enough to cover all their costs (and hopefully a little extra), and the customer leaves happy despite paying more. The downsides in the long-term are that (1) as time goes on and currency inflates, portion sizes get larger and (2) people get used to larger portion sizes and the same meal has less value to the customer over time. I don't have any data to back this up, but I do believe this sort of feedback loop plays a role in obesity.
- PeterisP 8y agoIt's not something that would/should explain the difference between USA and, say, Europe - the exact same things you mention as a possible holdover from the great depression of 1920s are also observed elsewhere as a holdover from the generation experiencing food scarcity/rationing/starvation in WW2 and the aftermath of it; UK or Germany had food issues into the 1950s but it doesn't have the same effect on obesity as in USA.
- robmaister 8y agoAs a single data point, I live in the US and I've lost ~45lbs over a year and a half by aggressively reducing my portion sizes (to the point where the average meal from a restaurant is comfortably two meals for me), significantly reducing my excess sugar and sweetener intake, and making sure I get a few thousand steps in every day (probably like 5-6k on average). I don't follow a particular diet, I try to make my own meals, and I don't sweat it if I want to have a cookie or slice of cake every once in a while, and it's been really working for me. This was prompted by an annual checkup with my doctor. I was 265lbs (6'0" tall) at 23 and had a number of issues related to my weight, including high cholesterol and an inflamed liver. My last annual checkup, I was down I think 30-35lbs and everything they tested was back in the normal range. So yeah, portion sizes are important.
- Fej 8y ago1. Portion sizes are smaller. 2. Sugar. So much sugar. Specifically, corn syrup. The agricultural lobby has successfully obtained so much in the way of subsidies that corn syrup is actually cheaper than cane sugar. It's in everything. Even bread has sugar of some sort added. You know there's a problem when bread brands place advertisements on the packaging that it "contains no corn syrup or high fructose corn syrup".