4 ms·
Indians with large amounts of hard currency are usually involved in some sort of tax evasive maneuver and sometimes involved in criminal activity. Corrupt polit
by primitivesuave 8y ago
Indians with large amounts of hard currency are usually involved in some sort of tax evasive maneuver and sometimes involved in criminal activity. Corrupt politicians will use enormous amounts of currency to influence elections, so in this case the party in power (BJP, similar in ideology to US Republican party) used demonetization to disarm other political parties before the elections while appearing hard on corruption.
There are numerous ways that wealthy individuals and businesses got around demonetization - for example, a bank manager could spread a large amount of "black money" across multiple accounts in the names of existing account holders, deposit a minimum deposit to avoid reporting requirements, and then withdraw the original amount later (minus a 20% commission) and return it in the form of new currency. The only people who were hurt were the average people who had to stand in long ATM lines or withstand reduced economic volatility. An established business may be able to withstand a month of severely reduced business but a street vendor, laborer, service worker, etc (a large part of the population) could not.
* The political disarming is from my own speculation and the Washington Post wrote a great article on the economic impact: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2017/01/23/narendra-modi-is-pulling-india-back-to-the-1970s/?utm_term=.c0916ef3bce0 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2017/...
- balladeer 8y ago> The only people who were hurt were the average people This is exactly what my experience and observation have been too! Even the upper middle class folks had the work around ready and at times recommended to them by their bank managers. I work in Bangalore (South) but I am from UP (North) and one thing, in both the regions, I learned from traders and rich people regarding demonetisation that it was not more than a minor or major (in many cases when too much black money was involved) annoyance for them. PS. I am from the region that borders Nepal. A lot of money was moved to Nepal during that period as demonetisation apparently didn't apply to INR in circulation in Nepal (INR is quite common there).