3 ms·
Tangent: I wish papers that get published contained a section with the reviewers' notes.
by curiousgal 8y ago
Tangent: I wish papers that get published contained a section with the reviewers' notes.
- sampo 8y ago> I wish papers that get published contained a section with the reviewers' notes. At least the journals published by the European Geosciences Union publish the whole review process in the open. Reviewers' comments, and authors' responses to them. https://www.egu.eu/publications/open-access-journals/ https://www.egu.eu/publications/open-access-journals/ (When you open the view to any article in any of those journals, you need to click on the "Peer review" tab, and you get to see the original manuscript as "Discussion paper", and all of the review process.)
- twic 8y agoCurrent Anthropology does this - see the 'comments' starting on page 407 of this paper, for example: https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdfplus/10.1086/698936 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdfplus/10.1086/698936 I have no idea if this is standard in anthropology. I am not an anthropologist, nor do i play one on television.