3 ms·
(Shrug) They had the option to do the right thing and maintain their final rejection. So why didn't they? It's hard to escape the conclusion that they just co
by CamperBob2 8y ago
(Shrug) They had the option to do the right thing and maintain their final rejection. So why didn't they?
It's hard to escape the conclusion that they just couldn't be bothered.
- anfilt 8y agoAgreed. The fact they were allowed to resumbit such a broad patent with obvious prior art is ridiculous.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoThey amended the claims which required the examiner to do another search. As mentioned above, Final Rejection just means you have to pay more money to continue the patent prosecution. This is called a Request for Continued Examination. RCEs are common. Generally, the initial filing fees provide for two rounds of examination -- a non-final rejection and then a final rejection. If the applicant re-filed the same claims that were rejected in the final rejection (w/o amending them), the examiner can issue an immediate final rejection on a subsequent RCE if he disagrees with the argument the applicant might have supplied.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoThe last amendment to the claims narrowed them to the extent that the patent is useless. The examiner knew this and allowed the patent.