4 ms·
This idea that wealth is somehow related to creating value, and these kinds of incentives are necessary in order to induce people to do this kind of work, is a
by lisper 8y ago
This idea that wealth is somehow related to creating value, and these kinds of incentives are necessary in order to induce people to do this kind of work, is a deliberate marketing ploy, and a fairly recent one at that, pretty much dating back only to the 1970s or so. Before that, the kinds of professions we today associate with being "rich and famous" (as if these two things were inherently related to each other somehow) -- actors, sports players, inventors -- were not particularly well paid. Before the 19th century, there was no such thing as a professional athlete. There were professional actors, but that was considered a borderline dishonorable profession. The history of invention since the industrial revolution is chock full of people who made important technological or scientific breakthroughs who never made a dime off their work. Most early science was done by people who were already rich, mostly through inherited wealth, or people who, like today, had wealthy patrons. The truly rich were, still are, and have always been, the ones in a position and with the inclination to bend the system to their advantage by whatever means they could.
- nv-vn 8y agoI mean, it is still related to value in the economic sense, but not necessarily the intuitive sense. For example, the Kardashians are certainly "worth" less in cultural value than custodians, but their economic value is much higher because they're much more scarce/have much higher demand. I think that this concept is something that many people on both sides of this debate haven't really taken the time to think about. It definitely does invalidate a lot of the statements like "poor people are just lazy" and it does highlight that capitalism is an ugly system. But at the same time (roughly paraphrasing Churchill) "Capitalism is the worst form of economics, except for all the other ones"
- lisper 8y agoIt's true that the Kardashians are in high demand. It does not necessarily follow that we as a society should allow them as a consequence to accumulate disproportionate wealth and influence. The incentive argument in particular falls apart here. Do we really need to pay the Kardashians a boatload of money to incentivize them to do whatever it is that they do? Or would it be OK if we taxed the shit out of them and took the risk that they would quit as a result? That seems like a no-brainer to me (in every possible sense).
- dogma1138 8y agoAnderson Cooper has a higher networth than Kim Kardashian are you ok with taxing him until he quits as well?
- lisper 8y agoAbsolutely. I'm OK with getting rid of anyone who is doing what they are doing solely for the money.
- dogma1138 8y agoGetting rid off... straight to the concentration camp? P.S. I also do what I do only for money, please let me know to which camp I should report too.
- lisper 8y agoOh, give me a break. I obviously meant I was OK with those people quitting their jobs.
- dogma1138 8y agoNearly everyone would quit their job if it would be more beneficial to take an easier job that pays just as much, i think you grossly overestimate the amount of people that are that driven by their career that it would take precedence over their actual life. And ok say you weren't planning to go the final solution route just yet, why should I be fired for just wanting to exchange my time for money based on the maximum (in my pocket) market value I can extract from it? Is it more morally superior to be so devoted to my job that I would do it even for free or for nothing more than minimum wage? that's some really fantastic way of life you got there....
- lisper 8y ago> why should I be fired I didn't say you should be fired. I said I would be OK with you quitting voluntarily. Also, we have had much higher incremental tax rates in the past (notably in the 40 years between the end of WWII and Reagan, and the U.S. economy did just fine, so I see no reason that should be any different now.
- gus_massa 8y ago> Before the 19th century, there was no such thing as a professional athlete. There were professional actors, but that was considered a borderline dishonorable profession. And that changed with TV (and cinema). In the 19th century an actor can play in front of one or two hundred persons each day at most. Now a good movie can be played in front of millions of persons. The same changes applies to sports.
- dogma1138 8y agoIt’s not that different today the vast majority of actors today are not rich or even well paid. A list actors are and that hasn’t changed at all. Historically “traveling” actors were often looked down on not that differently than say street performers or your Hollywood “acting waitresses” that gets a few gigs a year as an extra. However the historical equivalent of A list actors would be acting groups like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Chamberlain%27s_Men https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Chamberlain%27s_Men or https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Strange%27s_Men https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Strange%27s_Men. And even in the 16th century many famous actors became very wealthy take the likes of Edward Alleyn and William Knell for example.
- dogma1138 8y agoYou know who else didn’t get paid in the 19th century? Computer programmers. Things change the reason why entertainment professionals are paid more these days is because we have the ability to leverage their product through modern technology and the fact that the abundance of resources that even developing countries have today allows people to value entertainment. And no most scientists were not rich by any means outside of a few in the UK many of them were quite poor and were often living on a stipend provided by institutions or private patrons. And sorry to burst your bubble but A list actors historically became very wealthy in countries where entertainment was appreciated.
- lisper 8y agoIt's true that economic conditions change with technological advances, and that the general trend is that fewer and fewer people are required to meet the demand for any particular product. It does not follow that we as a society should adopt a policy that those who manage to capture markets are entitled to a proportionate (note that I deliberately did NOT say DISproportionate) share of society's wealth. Most of our social mores were designed under the assumption that production, not consumption, was the limiting factor in our economies. But that is starting to change. If we don't change the rules to accord with this new reality it will cause serious problems. If only 1% of the world's population is required to meet 110% of the world's demand for everything (and that could very well happen within our lifetimes), what are we going to do with the remaining 99%?
- dogma1138 8y agoThe problem is then what is proportionate and how do you estimate it? Should Apple be taxed more than Google? Should an actor that gets paid 10 million dollars for a movie be taxed more than an actor who’s paid 5? What if the actor that is paid 10 is has 5 times more views just in less valued markets? Should I who works as an engineer for a financial institution be taxed more than an engineer working for SpaceX or NASA?
- lisper 8y ago