3 ms·
It's by and large not possible for the state to change the parenting practices of actual parents; if it were, the innumerable attempts from the Progressive era
by jseliger 16y ago
It's by and large not possible for the state to change the parenting practices of actual parents; if it were, the innumerable attempts from the Progressive era forward would have been successful. It's also not possible to make large-scale systemic reforms and changes of schools without somehow dealing with the problems of teachers' unions: if you don't somehow deal with the problem of teachers who aren't just bad, but who actively don't care or aren't learning how to teach better, the idea that you can effectively implement the kinds of changes you're talking about is improbable at best.
It says a lot about America that our most popular school reform movie is targeted at people who don't read books.
I read books and haven't watched the movie, but in effect if not intent you're arguing for the status quo. You can't change the status quo without changing the teachers' unions. You can't easily negotiate with them either, so charter schools are an imperfect but useful way of isolating the problem to the extent possible.
- Alex3917 16y agoI completely agree with reforming the unions. Ideally we would just eliminate them. The only problem is that will never happen because schools have a 100+ year history of being extremely abusive toward teachers. The unions prevent any real change for the better, but they also keep a lot of bad stuff out of school as well.
- easp 16y agoThe unions are easy scapegoats, but as you point out, there is a reason they are what they are. Let's also not forget that the good old days of American schooling depended on a society where slightly over half the population had severely limited opportunities in the workforce. Even with the unions, teachers wages were depressed, and the entire profession devalued because other careers and jobs weren't open to women.
- kkowalczyk 16y agoIs there something special about U.S. that makes schools abusive towards teachers? Because there are many countries without teacher unions that don't abuse teachers.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoYes. The U.S. has always had a popular culture that is deeply anti-intellectual and teachers are (or were, at one point) a form of intellectual.
- Alex3917 16y ago"Is there something special about U.S. that makes schools abusive towards teachers?" For one thing our puritanical roots. Before unions teachers regularly got fired for things like interracial dating, going to a bar, being in town after dark, etc.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoDo you have any reason to believe the US would continue these practices if we eliminated unions today? Way back in 1910 small town America, you could be fired from all sorts of respectable professions for many of the things you mentioned. Certainly, no one would want their money manager doing disreputable things like what you mention. And yet even without a union, I've managed to avoid getting fired for interracial dating. I've even gone to a bar in town after dark with my boss! I think you are engaging in the post-hoc fallacy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc
- easp 16y agoThe state may or may not be able to improve the parenting practices of actual parents, but it definitely can wage a decades long "war on drugs" that disproportionately ensnares the poor and minorities in the legal system and follows up on that by imposing disproportionately severe sentences on them. By doing so, it can help tilt the balance towards bad parenting in such communities by ensuring that more children in those communities only have a single custodial parent, at best. But please, let's continue to act like we can solve the problem by demonizing the teachers unions.