3 ms·
>Hollywood's answer to the problem has been to double down on the community. Hollywood's answer to the problem is unions. Screenwriters have unions. Actors ha
by slg 8y ago
>Hollywood's answer to the problem has been to double down on the community.
Hollywood's answer to the problem is unions. Screenwriters have unions. Actors have unions. Directors have unions. Even the people who provide food on the sets of movies have a union. Hollywood doesn't care about "community" any more than the video game industry. They just realized that there are more people who want to work in the entertainment industry than there are available jobs and a union was the best way to protect themselves from being taken advantage of because of that fact.
- drakonka 8y agoI think it's worthwhile pointing out that it isn't like game developers don't have unions. Maybe if you're talking about the US exclusively sure, but there are parts of the world where employees in the game development industry do have active union representation (which as one such employee is very much appreciated).
- lentil_soup 8y agoCurious to know where you are based. I've not heard of game developer unions in Europe either.
- drakonka 8y agoI'm in Sweden, where most people are in a union. It doesn't have to be a union specific to game development (although I think one may exist, I'm not sure). I'm in a general union called Unionen. Even though it's not a union specific to the game development industry, they have a lot of power and work with the government, companies, and employees to monitor and improve work conditions and employee protections. For example, last year a series of meetings was held at our workplace between interested employees and union representatives, resulting in a new collective bargain agreement which formalised a flex hours policy and gave us an extra paid week off per year (partly to address the overtime we tend to do). I've heard of cases where employees called in their union representative to help them work through issues with the employer, negotiate better termination agreements, etc. Basically it's a normal union that does union-y things :)
- redisman 8y agoIn Finland at least game devs fall under some general IT collective bargaining agreement, so they have union presentation but it's more general software/IT. Works decently. From my experience the games industry is a bit too... wild(?) to really think about things like unions by itself.
- jahaja 8y agoThe problem in Sweden is of a different nature. We do have union representation in the game industry, but it's more or less a yellow union (that is, it's so passive that it's to the benefit of the employers) imo. This means that many of the core issues related to employee health are never adressed or fought over, for example: * Overtime pay (very rare of in the game industry). * The allowed amount of hours overtime (a.k.a. crunch, there's alooot of hours overtime allowed in the collective bargaining agreement). * The detrimental effect of open offices. So understand me right, I'm a union man without a doubt, but just having the union box checked does nothing. The union has to be a fighting union, otherwise it will wither away.
- vinceguidry 8y agoHollywood's answer to a part of the problem, that of how to take care of the people that are already in the system, is unions. How to take care of the people that aren't in the system yet but really really want to be, that's the problem I'm talking about. I live in Atlanta, huge movie and TV presence here, I rub shoulders with actors and all kinds of workers. The people who are in the system are extremely quick to lend a helpful ear or advice or stopgap job here and there. The whole system is set up to gently shake the talent pool so that people eventually find the part of the industry that they can find a foothold in that won't kill them. The people who do wind up as grips or whatever can still nurture their creative side and there's still quite a bit of glory in working on that side of it. Hollywood, somehow, has figured out how to stop eating its young and start nurturing them.
- slg 8y agoI would argue that unions are a direct cause of some of that behavior. Union members generally don't have to fear new competition the way non-union workers do. They don't have to fear someone doing their job at 90% of the quality for 50% of the salary. Non-union workers have a disincentive to mentor people who immediately become their competition for jobs. Unions help remove that disincentive and allows members to function as a single cooperative group instead of as individual people competing against each other for the same opportunities.