2 ms·
Abandoning notions of boolean and aristotelian logic at the outset is the first step toward success in understanding developments. Children have to invent thei
by ncmncm 8y ago
Abandoning notions of boolean and aristotelian logic at the outset is the first step toward success in understanding developments.
Children have to invent their own logic, and then discover words that fit it. Only later do they learn about other logics, and adjust. Most never get to Boole, never mind Aristotle, but what they have works well enough for what they expect of it. At the same time, they are inventing causality, which formal logic still has not absorbed, and that most statisticians remain deeply suspicious of.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 8y agoAlso boolean logic does not concern "all", "any" and "no" (as in no cookies), these are from prepositional logic But I agree with your point, mathematical logic is a consequence of something that originated with human thinking
- vorg 8y ago"all" and "no" are easily extended from boolean logic to unspecified numbers of items for everyday speech, without resorting to unification: all not == not A and not B == not (A or B) not all == not (A and B) == not A or not B Seems to work in other natural languages besides English, e.g. 都不 vs 不都 have same variation in meaning as in English where 都="all" and 不="not".
- empath75 8y agoThe article leads with exactly that statement. She’s talking about logic as colloquially used: ‘if it’s cloudy, it’s probably going to rain later’. People don’t learn formal rules, but they still make statement that are logical in nature.