5 ms·
This doesn't the answer the "how does cloned consciousness work" question. For re-vitilization, I don't give a fuck if it's a perfect copy of me walking around
by komali2 8y ago
This doesn't the answer the "how does cloned consciousness work" question.
For re-vitilization, I don't give a fuck if it's a perfect copy of me walking around. I want it to be me, the current stream of consciousness. To the abyss I say, no thank you.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoI agree – if the cloned/copied/othewise renewed consciousness is not that which is currently residing in my head right now, there’s really no point to it, no matter how much philosophically it might be “me”. The only situation I can envision a clone/copy being satisfactory is that in which I had some grand goal larger than myself that I wished to complete and could hand off to the clone.
- 1996 8y agoif it is a copy of me good enough to remember my memories, good enough. Whether my "clone" shares my goal or not is not my problem. If it ends up being a totally different person, so be it. Free determination is more important than my personal survival. I am making a bet, that is better than the alternative of 0 chances. If I did everything I could, why should I be concerned about the actual outcome? A bet is a bet, not a guarantee.
- red75prime 8y agoI wonder where this strong intuition about consciousness comes from. Your "the current stream of consciousness" idea requires existence of something beyond all the information you have conscious access to and the procedures your brain performs. Namely, some "marker" which makes this particular realization of your consciousness unique, and which cannot be copied in any circumstances. What do you think this "marker" is?
- komali2 8y agoWell, that's the question. Since theoretically if I can be reconstituted perfectly, I can be copied perfectly, it is more incomprehensible to me to that two identical consciousnesses exist (two Me's with a capital M) than it is that Me is unique somehow, I work from the second assumption. Questions that still need answering include "what about slow cellular replacement with electronic parts?", to which I have no answer. What do you think the marker is?
- red75prime 8y agoI think there's no marker. Both instances of you feel like each of them is you, if the copying was sufficiently faithful. Concepts of the original and the copy are external to them. When you imagine the situation you take a place of external observer who has the information about who is the original and who is the copy. ETA: It's something like imaging your death. You cannot truthfully imagine it first person, and (imperceptibly) slip into third person view.
- robotresearcher 8y agoBetter not go to sleep then. You woke up from the abyss this morning.
- komali2 8y agoI have real deal insomnia for this exact reason.
- speakeron 8y ago> You woke up from the abyss this morning. Actually I woke up directly (and, apparently, seamlessly) from a dream. (I went lucid a little too carelessly surged to a waking in the same manner as you come up from the bottom of a swimming pool). To be fair, though, I did wake up into the dream from the abyss. But since the abyss is timelessness, how would we know the difference?