4 ms·
If you check out http://jonls.dk/redshift/ http://jonls.dk/redshift/ you will note that they provide a sample configuration in what appears to be toml where eac
by michaelmrose 8y ago
If you check out http://jonls.dk/redshift/ http://jonls.dk/redshift/ you will note that they provide a sample configuration in what appears to be toml where each option is annotated example
; Global settings for redshift
[redshift]
; Set the day and night screen temperatures
temp-day=5700
temp-night=3500
There are all of 9 settings in the default config with lots of explanations.
The level of challenge required to copy some text into a text file with the syntax
[section]
settingname=value
and change the values relevant to you is very modest.
People are prone to overestimate the difficulty of anything without a gui in fact its often like this.
Incidentally there appear to be a number of different guis for example on kde you could use
https://phabricator.kde.org/source/plasma-redshift-control/ https://phabricator.kde.org/source/plasma-redshift-control/
To see the how this looks see
https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/widgets-linux-plasma-applets/ https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/widgets-linux-plasma-applets/
This post sums of peoples misperception of linux perfectly.
- overcast 8y agoBy virtue of the fact that your post is so long just to explain how "easy" it is to configure, sums up the Linux community perfectly.
- michaelmrose 8y agoIt could be summarized thusly in 2 sentences. The text configuration is so easy anyone could do it once in 2 minutes and not worry about it for the next 10 years. It actually has a gui in fact multiple guis for this particular app based on platform. If I mangled it and removed punctuation it might fit in a tweet but this wouldn't be as illuminating as actually showing how simple the configuration format is or linking to an actual frontend so you could see how it looks. We write posts longer than tweets because we care about care about communicating ideas of value.
- overcast 8y agoText configuration is so far beyond that vast majority of end users. Hacker News truly is living in a bubble.
- michaelmrose 8y agoI could train a computer illiterate to open a text file and change foo=bar to foo=Baz. Not to mention most things including red shift actually have a gui.
- gregknicholson 8y agoThe majority of users would either (A) not care about their screen's colour temperature at all, or (B) just turn on Night Light using Gnome's settings. Redshift is very much a niche tool.
- pasabagi 8y agoNon-text configuration is beyond me. Changing text files is easy because I already know how to use a text editor. Changing something in a labyrinthine set of nested GUI menus that may or may not contain the option you want, that has no comments, is kinda horrible. And it's even more horrible if you end up editing hexidecimal values in regedit. I know there's this theoretical 'end user' who likes to point and click, but honestly, I've never met them. People who don't like computers just don't do configuration - having a GUI or not is besides the point - other than the fact it makes the howto of configuration difficult to communicate and specific to every app.
- overcast 8y agoYou really are out of touch with the end users of most software then. You're not living in the corporate world dealing with them, and troubleshooting their issues. Most people come into work, click on the same exact shortcut on their desktop, type in the same exact data all day, and then leave. If that shortcut is missing for some reason, they can not do their job. If ANYTHING deviates from the norm, they can not do their job. Full stop. Could they type in the address of that web app without the shortcut? Of course, but they have NO clue what that even means. Copy and paste with the keyboard? That's a revelation to most. Many can't even type without looking at the keyboard. This is clearly a foreign world to you. Which is fine, but please don't act like you and your peers are anywhere near the other 99% of computer users. This is EXACTLY what people talk about when a discussion comes up about developers creating things for themselves, and not their end users.
- 8note 8y agowow, you keep your laptop for a very long time
- michaelmrose 8y agoIt's a config file when I get a new machine I copy my config files over. Not everything decides to rewrite in an incompatible fashion every 2 years. With a gui interface you install fresh and configure to your liking each time. With a file you could switch out your entire os and not have to reconfigure your apps.
- Matt3o12_ 8y agoBut that is not the point. For people who have never edited a config file, this seems quite strange. They wouldn’t know which editor to use, how to properly save the file and, most importantly, how to apply the config file. Chances are, I couldn’t do it intuitively. My go to way would be to just use systemctl restart but not all Unix systems use systemd. And if you start it using the desktop GUI, systemd is not used, so I have to “ps aus | grep redshift“, copy the PID (or process name) and use kill or killall. Sometimes this doesn’t work because it gives me 10 pids because it spawned so many children and I don’t have killall installed. This is not very difficult if you have done it before, but there is steep learning curve before you can do it and quite different from “check a few boxes and click apply”. I personally prefer the config file way because it gives you way better control over your system (especially if a config file causes crashes due to a bug), it is way easier to backup and restore without guessing (program X uses 5 different paths for its gui files) and you can distribute changes easier and without the help of a specialized program. But this sums up the Linux experience quite well IMO: there are many advantages to using Linux and once you have gasped the basics, everything is less scary. But the learning curve is quite steep especially if you have never done anything like it so not many people use it and therefore there are less Linux applications. Furthermore there is also more variety which means the way I know to do might not work for your Linux distro or the old server I’m ssh’ing into.
- lozf 8y ago> if you start it using the desktop GUI, systemd is not used, so I have to “ps aus | grep redshift“, copy the PID (or process name) and use kill or killall. Or, since you started it with the GUI, you could just choose "quit" from the menu that appears when you click on it.
- starsinspace 8y agoA novice user will not even find the config file, or the place to store it in. Because for reasons of antiquated tradition, Linux still uses this concept of dot-files and -directories, and redshift's config is somewhere in ".config". So if a beginner user uses, say, GEdit to create that config file, and then wants to save it... they will probably end up staring blankly at their home folder contents in the GEdit file save dialog, searching for this ".config" folder, not finding it.