3 ms·
How is that different from selling a used car that's no longer under warranty? If this ever gets litigated, is a court likely to make a decision that undermines
by greenyoda 8y ago
How is that different from selling a used car that's no longer under warranty? If this ever gets litigated, is a court likely to make a decision that undermines the U.S. used car market? Or is the company hoping that it can intimidate sellers into backing down without ever having to go to court?
I suppose that it would be stupid for car manufacturers to attempt to put restrictions on resale, since that would significantly reduce the value of a car. But the same thing could happen to games: if someone knows that they can't resell a game if they get tired of playing it, they'd be somewhat less likely to buy it in the first place (or not be willing to spend as much for it).
- seanalltogether 8y agoThe arguments only apply to the sale of copyrighted material, not general goods.
- ikeboy 8y agoWarranty is used to get around first sale rights for trademarks, not copyrights. The argument is the trademark can no longer be used if the goods are "materially different", such as by not having a warranty.
- sandworm101 8y agoWont stand up in court. This is about trademarks ... ie "Ford" or "BMW". Such a ruling would kill the entire used car industry. Not going to happen anytime soon.