5 ms·
I'm not sure who the two authors of this piece are but they are distressingly naïve and their sweeping statements ignore the real issues. > The reason we have
by gumby 8y ago
I'm not sure who the two authors of this piece are but they are distressingly naïve and their sweeping statements ignore the real issues.
> The reason we have electronic voting machines in the first place was due to the "hanging chad" problem in the Bush v. Gore election of the year 2000.
The reason electronic voting machines are now so common in the US is indeed a result of the 2000 presidential election, but it was at the time a panicked reaction that also ignored the advice of computer security professionals (and followed the wishes and claims of voting machine vendors)
> After that election, a wave of new, software-based, voting machines replaced the older inaccurate paper machines.
A nice statement, characterizing paper-based machines as "inaccurate" and implying software is not. But there has been no serious study of this issue, which implies that people don't care either way.
> ...If [accidents vs. intentional attack is the] measure, then voting machine software is fine and perfectly trustworthy. Such machines are no more likely to accidentally record a wrong vote than the paper voting systems they replaced -- indeed less likely.
Again, a sweeping, unsupported statement. When I work on software that people actually care about (e.g. system control for power plants, trains, aircraft and other vehicles; medical devices) there's a huge amount of attention paid not just to classical security but also reliability, resilience, correctness etc. Audits of voting software have never shown concern for these matters -- everything I've seen has been written with the same level of care as for an e-commerce website.
> To repeat: software is better than the mechanical machines they replaced, which is why there are so many software-based machines in the United States.
I could assert, and repeat, that the moon is 90% made of quartz, and for all I know that could be true, but I have no real data on the question.
- jiveturkey 8y agogreat tear down, thanks
- specialist 8y agoAs a recovering election integrity activist, I agree with gumby.