2 ms·
I think I said profit margins are set by competition and then you said something like no, profit margins are determined by competition. Is your point that they
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
I think I said profit margins are set by competition and then you said something like no, profit margins are determined by competition.
Is your point that they aren't set by competition in uncompetitive markets? Because in that case the margins would typically be more than 25% to begin with and taxing monopolies and price-fixing cartels is something most people can get behind.
What you could be alluding to is that imposing tariffs could reduce competition from foreign suppliers, allowing domestic suppliers to sustain higher margins if there isn't sufficient domestic competition to keep them down. But high margins should attract new domestic competitors absent some high barrier to entry, higher margins for domestic companies is not hard to classify as "benefit" rather than "disaster" anyway, and the maximum increase is still capped at the amount of the tariff or people would go back to the foreign supplier(s).
- jacquesm 8y ago> and then you said something like no, profit margins are determined by competition. No, I did not say that. I said that competition is in some cases a factor but definitely not the major ingredient. Profit margins are not an input into some calculation, they are the result of a calculation.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoI'm just not seeing how the thing you said is supposed to be in conflict with the thing I said. Sure, competition isn't the only factor in margins. But it is a major determinant of how much of the total surplus goes to the consumer rather than the producer. And the point was that if you raise costs for all competitors, it isn't necessarily fatal to the market that the amount is larger than their original margins, as long as it isn't larger than the total producer+consumer surplus. Because when everyone's costs increase by the same amount, the producers may be able to pass some of the cost on to the consumers.