3 ms·
Ironically, software is replacing pilots and their checklists. Check lists are essential in planes because they are complex machines with traditionally low leve
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Ironically, software is replacing pilots and their checklists. Check lists are essential in planes because they are complex machines with traditionally low levels of automation. This creates extremely high workloads for pilots. The only way to deal with that is checklists.
The solution is automation. Compare a modern fadec engine with a 50 year old piston engine. The engine manages itself. You basically turn it on and it regulates itself. There are still checklists of course but they are a lot shorter. Similarly fly by wire, auto pilots, etc. have reduced workloads. There is still plenty of opportunity to fix things.
Software could do with a lot more checks and balances. But you have to balance the workload, overhead with the added value. Also, you need to think about automation. Continuous deployment is basically doing exactly that. It can only be done if you have automated tests and deployments.
- dredmorbius 8y agoThis gets to the problems of excessive automation: forgetting, skill loss, and detraining, among experienced operators, and a lack of experience gain amongst new entrants. We're starting to see this in particular in areas without entrance barriers or continuous training requirements, noteably automobile operation. This is compounded by novel and nonuniform interfaces.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoIt's sad at a sentimental level but at the same time, the aviation industry provides plenty of statistical material on safety. The general trend of getting humans out of the way through automation is a good one. Checklists are critical to make sure humans don't fail to do something. Anything they don't have to do is an item less on the checklist and one less thing that can go wrong. With many modern planes the startup check list is "push the start button". Of course you still have the pre-flight checklists and other checklists but engine management is typically fully automated. That means no more complex failure modes because of cowl flap management, wrong mixture or prop settings, over torquing the engine, etc.
- dredmorbius 8y agoAviation controlls the operator class. Automotive does not.