2 ms·
>If stricter enforcement of red lights leads to fewer people cycling, it might lead to more deaths overall. I did not call for stricter enforcement. Cyclists c
by foldr 8y ago
>If stricter enforcement of red lights leads to fewer people cycling, it might lead to more deaths overall.
I did not call for stricter enforcement. Cyclists could choose to stop running red lights without any changes in the law or how it is enforced.
>You asked about who or what was "causing" the issue.
You seem in effect to be saying that we can’t blame cyclists for running red lights here in the real world because you can imagine some kind of cycletopia where lights wouldn’t necessary. If a cyclist runs a red light and consequently crashes into me while I'm crossing the road, the cause of that accident is, obviously, the cyclist and not the light. Removing the light isn't going to make bikes any easier to see, or cyclists any more careful. (Those of a careful disposition wouldn't be running red lights at pedestrian crossings in the first place.)
Cyclists are free to argue for different traffic regulations and infrastructure, but in the mean time, they should follow the rules and stop endangering others.
- lmm 8y ago> Cyclists could choose to stop running red lights without any changes in the law or how it is enforced. True, but that would carry a similar risk of leading them to cycle less. > After all, the accident would have happened just the same if the light wasn't there. Disagree; you would likely have acted differently if the light wasn't there. If you were right, we'd see cyclists colliding with pedestrians at no-motor-traffic junctions all the time, since none of them have lights. But we don't.
- foldr 8y ago>True, but that would carry a similar risk of leading them to cycle less. Nonsense. >you would likely have acted differently if the light wasn't there. I don't act differently when there are no lights, since I know that most cyclists ignore the lights anyway! >If you were right, we'd see cyclists colliding with pedestrians at no-motor-traffic junctions all the time, since none of them have lights. But we don't. Cyclists are harder to see when there are cars on the road, so that's an irrelevant comparison. In any case, cyclists do collide with pedestrians in the absence of motor vehicles. The canal tow paths in London are particularly bad for this, for example: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/oct/03/transport.cyclingholidays https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/oct/03/transport.cycling...
- lmm 8y ago> I don't act differently when there are no lights, since I know that most cyclists ignore the lights anyway! Then it sounds like cyclists ignoring the lights aren't putting you in any real danger, and that "cyclists choosing to stop running red lights" as you suggest would do you very little good. > In any case, cyclists do collide with pedestrians in the absence of motor vehicles. They do, occasionally. But notice how no-one in that article even mentions the possibility of introducing traffic lights, because they're so obviously not a solution to anything.
- foldr 8y ago>Then it sounds like cyclists ignoring the lights aren't putting you in any real dange That is simply a non sequitur. >"cyclists choosing to stop running red lights" as you suggest would do you very little good. It would stop them frequently nearly crashing into me, which would certainly be good from my perspective. >But notice how no-one in that article even mentions the possibility of introducing traffic lights Erm, because it wouldn't be possible to add traffic lights on a canal tow path. The point is that ignoring traffic lights is dangerous, not that traffic lights should be put everywhere. https://www.gasholder.london/2017/02/09/cyclists-vs-pedestrians/ https://www.gasholder.london/2017/02/09/cyclists-vs-pedestri...
- lmm 8y ago> It would stop them frequently nearly crashing into me, which would certainly be good from my perspective. I don't advocate crashing into pedestrians. But the best way to avoid crashing into pedestrians is to pay attention to pedestrians, not to lights. > Erm, because it wouldn't be possible to add traffic lights on a canal tow path. The point is that ignoring traffic lights is dangerous None of your articles seems to think that traffic lights are helpful.