3 ms·
The particular truths sought matter less for most jobs than the amount of research and critical thinking along the way. Sadly, as has been pointed out, the hum
by zdragnar 8y ago
The particular truths sought matter less for most jobs than the amount of research and critical thinking along the way.
Sadly, as has been pointed out, the humanities have become a monoculture of thought and encourage rote initiation into the groupthink, rather than independent research and analysis.
Of course, that won't get you most STEM jobs, but it would have a lot more practical application, and therefore economic value, for most other white collar jobs- at least compared to the current degrees.
- Retric 8y agoHaving approximately zero math skills is a huge detriment across a wide range of jobs. The specific STEM program may not be that useful after collage, but the overlap is going to help when crunching numbers in Excel. By comparison while most jobs need basic proficiency reading and understanding a written language, that's also part of a STEM degree.
- organsnyder 8y agoI've found that In my career as a software developer, I rarely have a need for any math beyond what I learned in high school (set theory being the one exception).
- r_smart 8y agoBut you're really just one small part of the E in STEM. Others use math all the time.
- riskneutral 8y agoI think you mean the T in STEM.
- r_smart 8y agoWell, T is Technology and E is engineering. I will leave it up to any person in either category to decide where they go. My rough estimate was Sysadmin, IT support, etc is T. Electrical, Mechanical and Civil engineering are E, but I'll let software squeak in too I suppose.
- riskneutral 8y agoSTEM is a categorization of academic disciplines in K-12 and university education. Sysadmin and IT support are not academic disciplines. If software doesn’t fall under the (T)echnogy category in STEM then I don’t know what does.
- Retric 8y agoAircraft mechanics go to technical school. If you're maintaining something it's technical. Developing something it's engineering even if it's the same basic highway bridge and their are 10,000 that look the same you need to figure out what works for this area.
- zdragnar 8y agoProgramming software is a pretty substantial difference from computer science, and (at least when I went to school) there was in fact very little in the way of courses that would prepare you for a job doing either web or mobile development. Instead, you would learn all of the things that went into compilers, databases, and then optionally pick a specialized path such as AI, fluid dynamics modelling or what have you. The strongest direct use of maths was probably algebra until you focused on some of the more specialized fields. This is among the reasons, I think, why such a huge percentage of software programmers I met didn't even have a 4 year degree; it simply wasn't a practical requirement for baseline skill like you would expect from other careers.
- rhino369 8y ago>By comparison while most jobs need basic proficiency reading and understanding a written language, that's also part of a STEM degree. Only barely at some schools. I think I only had to take two writing and rhetoric classes in my EE program. My writing skills became worse than they were in highschool.
- geebee 8y agoI haven't done a full survey, but my overwhelming impression is that most universities do require very substantial humanities coursework for all students, including STEM student. I went to UC San Diego - check out the requirements at Revelle college: https://revelle.ucsd.edu/academics/general-education/index.html https://revelle.ucsd.edu/academics/general-education/index.h... This isn't unusual, many state or private university systems require this - and the humanities requirements for an engineering major are considerably more substantial than the math and science requirements for a humanities major. I like this emphasis on breadth, though I do think it may put graduates of US based programs at a disadvantage in PhD programs, as many of the international students focus more intensely on a specialty at the undergraduate level. Breadth is helpful, but it can put you at a disadvantage for the first couple of years of graduate coursework (in programs that have 33-50% attrition rates).