62 ms·
"prove that I'm the one that 'illegally disposed' of your or someone else's property that you attached surreptitiously to my car." Ok then I misunderstood your
by roel_v 16y ago
"prove that I'm the one that 'illegally disposed' of your or someone else's property that you attached surreptitiously to my car."
Ok then I misunderstood your remark, I thought you meant I had to prove "he is legally liable for those damages". But yeah if you turn it into a matter of evidence, anything goes, it becomes purely based on the specific circumstances. I was arguing the theoretical fundamentals.
"ownership is a pretty murky business from a legal point of view"
Eh no it's not. Transferring ownership is very widely studied, specified and understood. There is no discussion that the tracked subject doesn't get ownership. He does get possession, obviously. Nobody would argue otherwise. Again, if you bend this into an evidence case, all bets are off. In the concrete case the guy posted a picture of himself holding the device on the web. All the armchair lawyers saying 'oh he shouldn't give it back! it's now his!' don't know what they're talking about. I was in my original comment merely pointing out that this guy has no leg to stand on - he should just return the thing to the feds (well, he did) and save himself a lot of trouble.
"Cite a case please, and name the defendants lawyer,"
http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BH9929 http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BH9929
http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BM1166 http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BM1166
http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BM1192 http://www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp?ljn=BM1192
You can find the names of the lawyers in the various instances in the history of judgments.
These are just the cases where the judgments have been published, and where they were explicitly mentioned in the case. Also cases are only published when they have legal relevance, routine cases are not (they're not even written up if there's no appeal). Obviously most of these cases are handled 'behind the scenes'. Nobody ever knows that not everything went 100% 'by the book'. One case where (part of the) evidence was thrown out was when the police picked a guy up from work, threatened him, bullied him into silence after he repeatedly asked for a warrant, entered his house (without a warrant) through the neighbor's balcony, cuffed the suspect and threatened him and his mom to arrest him until he gave permission to search the house. This is about how bad it needs to get before evidence is excluded. I have no reason to believe these policemen were sanctioned.
"the police is not in a habit of going across the street phoning in illegally obtained evidence in order to 'launder' it."
Well it's all hearsay from here on, so we can go 'yes!' 'no!' for hours. I do think though you remember the IRT case; that's only 15 years ago! Also read accounts like http://www.koudbloed.nl/content/docs/robzijlstra.pdf http://www.koudbloed.nl/content/docs/robzijlstra.pdf.
Like I said, from here on it's no longer based on verifiable facts, not worth the trouble. I do think you have a too rosy picture of the practical workings of the justice system, though (note that I'm not making a moral judgment; I think overall it works pretty well. I'm just saying that it ain't like on Law and Order).