4 ms·
Here's the thing about voting. There are basically three kinds of fraud: fraud in counting votes (what independent monitors are meant to solve), fraud in castin
by jcranmer 8y ago
Here's the thing about voting. There are basically three kinds of fraud: fraud in counting votes (what independent monitors are meant to solve), fraud in casting votes (what voter ID is meant to solve), and fraud in inducing votes (such as voter intimidation). Unsurprisingly, in practice, almost all of the problems that actually occur with legitimate democracies, and even most of them in sham democracies, is with the last category of fraud. People who freak out about the insecurity of voting machines worry about the first two kinds of issues, and generally ignore the latter part.
- detaro 8y agoHow do voting machines help with the latter part?
- jcranmer 8y agoThey don't, but the point is that elections are already manipulated in that way, so that people aren't going to bother with a roundabout way of manipulating an election, when there's a much easier, less illegal (or at least, more opportunities for plausible deniability) way to do it.
- mcherm 8y agoOne example is that a voting machine (depending on how it is built) can either provide or fail to provide secrecy for the voter. If the fact that a voter cast a vote is public knowledge but HOW they voted is well concealed, then certain kinds of induced votes ("vote for the right guy or I'll beat you up afterward") are not possible.
- detaro 8y agoWhat specific attack scenario that works for paper ballots fails with a voting machine?
- adamlett 8y agoThe majority of countries where elections take place, don't have voting machines. So it's hardly surprising that most kinds of election fraud don't involve voting machines. Also, I am very sceptical of your claim that most of the problems belong to the last category. If it seems that way, I say that is because of observation bias. It's much easier to find evidence of voter intimidation than for fraudulent counting, even if both take place.
- p49k 8y agoHackable voting machines completely invalidate the safety provided by independent monitors, which is why people are concerned. It shifts the dynamic you’re speaking of.
- lucideer 8y agoI'm also curious about your source on the last category being most common. If by "most common" you mean "affecting most voters worldwide", it's possible a number of high-population countries with flagrant corruption in elections may bias this figure, but overall—particularly in, say, West Virginia (which I guess is what inspired this comic)—I would imagine the 3rd category would be the least prevalent, particularly as it's the easiest to detect.
- cuchoi 8y agoPeople who freak out about the insecurity of voting machines worry about the first two kinds of issues becoming issues. That's different from ignoring fraud in inducing votes.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> People who freak out about the insecurity of voting machines worry about the first two kinds of issues, and generally ignore the latter part. No, they don't, IME; many of the people most vocal about the vulnerability of voting machines are the exact same people active against voter intimidation and suppression. Conversely, many of the people who have historically most backed moves to vulnerable voting machines are also the same people practicing voter intimidation and suppression.
- kakwa_ 8y agopaper ballots are not perfect, but it's a proven technique with known processes and checks (double counting, check the number of votes match the number of ballots, people from various parties controlling the ballot, etc). Also, at least for national election, it's quite hard to manipulate such ballot wildly as there are heavily decentralized with a lot of individual polling places. It's quite hard to have a massive fraud on the ballot itself has you have fraud in hundreds of places. Now with the voting machine, you have one or a few central points where it could be possible to take over the voting machines and manipulate the vote on a large scale. Also, voting machine can be quite horrible. It's basically a computer that is only used once or twice a year. So it's likely that voting machines have a ton of CVE. Also, those are generally not very well made, with a lot of security holes, from physical attack to debug ports not removed, default passwords from the manufacturer not replace or bad configuration/lack of security in the software. The only use case for a voting machine that I could see is the following: Using a voting machine where when you cast your ballot, it prints a paper with the name of the candidate, after that you do it the 'old' way (envelope+ballot). When counting it's now possible to compare the paper ballot and the electronic one and check if everything matches. As a side effect, it reduces the quantity of paper required.