4 ms·
What problem is electronic voting trying to solve?
by rwmj 8y ago
What problem is electronic voting trying to solve?
- odyssey7 8y agoAnimal spirits.
- julvo 8y agoPotentially reducing cost while increasing voter turnout
- rwmj 8y agoWhere I live, the paper ballots are collected, moved and counted by volunteers (in big open halls and other public spaces where anyone can go along and watch). So I guess cost doesn't have to be an issue. Voter turnout: People prefer screens to paper or something? Sounds odd that voter turnout would be affected by the exact method of voting.
- r-bryan 8y agoMaybe we've been looking at the wrong cost. As you suggest, voting machines wouldn't make it cheaper to count the votes. They would make it cheaper to hack the election! "No matter how cynical I get, I just can't keep up." --Lily Tomlin
- deathanatos 8y agoI honesty don't see how electronic voting machines would increase voter turnout. How would there be a (significant) cause/effect there?
- peterwwillis 8y agoNot enough taxpayer money spent on things that aren't broken enough.
- skymt 8y agoThe 2000 presidential election was a big driver. No one wanted to spend November of an election year hearing about "chads" ever again, so the Help America Vote Act was passed. Among other things it provided federal funding for states to replace problematic punch-card voting machines. Electronic voting, in theory, could be easier to use than a paper ballot and can automatically check that the ballot is filled out correctly (e.g. not voting for multiple candidates for a single office). And of course there were companies lining up to help states spend those federal dollars on overpriced touchscreen PCs running Windows XP.
- grigjd3 8y agoNot saying the solution is valid or the problem is pressing, but they're trying to fix counting issues like "hanging chad".
- mcherm 8y agoSeveral things. The most important one (in my opinion) is the problem that the companies that sell voting machines aren't making enough money and their profits would be improved if enough county election boards were convinced (or required, though state or national legislation) to buy new systems. Another very significant problem that electronic voting is attempting to address is that election officials are evaluated (to some extent) by the public based on what appears in the newspaper on just one or two days per year -- and THAT depends largely on how quickly results are reported. So a tool that takes 2 hours to report results will look much better for election officials than a tool that takes 48 hours, even if the second produces elections that are more trustworthy and there are 2-3 months before the new candidates actually need to take office. Another problem is that existing methods using paper look "old-fashioned". A fancy system that takes video images of the voter's face to identify them and then allows them to vote from overseas using a cell phone may not be as reliable or secure as mailing in a paper ballot, but it sure FEELS modern. I guess my point is that there are definitely reasons these machines are being used, but "improved security" or "transparence and thus confidence in the reported results" are not the motivating forces.
- hutzlibu 8y ago" A fancy system that takes video images of the voter's face to identify them and then allows them to vote from overseas using a cell phone may not be as reliable or secure as mailing in a paper ballot" Sure about it? I mean I don't know if there are additional measures with mail voting, but opening a mail seems quite trivial to me. Just have someone in the mail working for you, to lookout for those letters.