7 ms·
I'm still boggled by the fact that people pay for cable TV service and then accept ads at all, let alone ads at the cost of messing with the actual content.
by taneq 8y ago
I'm still boggled by the fact that people pay for cable TV service and then accept ads at all, let alone ads at the cost of messing with the actual content.
- michaelt 8y agoIf you imagine you escape ads when you pay for content, you're going to be disappointed. Even Netflix does paid product placement in 74% of its original series [1] [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-hulu-netflix-driving-product-placement-deals-2018-6?IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-hulu-netflix-driving-...
- dantheman 8y agoProduct placement can vary in how intrusive it is. Reese's Pieces in ET is an example of good product placement. It's when it's obvious that it's a problem -- holding on the logo of a laptop, etc. If a character has to eat, drive, or use some real object -- you might as well use a real one and get paid instead of having to create a fake one.
- ArekDymalski 8y ago>Product placement can vary in how intrusive it is. Reese's Pieces in ET is an example of good product placement. Another great example is Hello Kitty in "Ant-Man and The Wasp". IMHO, it's a real masterpiece - several seconds of pure focus on the product in slow-motion. And people love the scene, becuase it's surprising, funny and well woven into whole sequence. Here's the relevant fragment of the trailer if you're interested: https://youtu.be/RPUH-FlVCPc?t=1m34s https://youtu.be/RPUH-FlVCPc?t=1m34s
- oblio 8y agoThat's different. It's waaaay less disruptive to see a Toyota logo in the background than to stop the whole show for 5 minutes or show those awful pop-over ads.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoThere was one scene in errr, Designated Survival where they made a very overt show to display a BMW remote start function (via smartphone). It didn't even have any practical use for the episode, the dude just stood a few feet outside his car to start it with his smartphone because ???????
- gaius 8y agoThere’s an episode of CSI Miami where someone says let’s have a video conference and someone else asks but is it secure and Horatio looks right at the camera and says of course it’s secure, it’s Cisco.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoCringe.
- dave7 8y agoMy favourite is CSI New York - "I'll create a GUI Interface using Visual Basic, see if I can track an IP address" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU
- genericid 8y agoDo you think that was product placement?
- dpcx 8y agoIt's definitely interesting reading my sibling comments - their complaint is that there are product logos in the shot of the program that is being watched. I have only anecdotal evidence, and it's not even recorded evidence, but I'd wager that the vast majority of these product placement shots take 30s or less from the entire program (often 30m or more). Personally, and of course this is just my opinion, but I would absolutely take product placement shots (even of the variety given by my sibling comments) over 2m of commercials every 10 minutes in the show.
- 8y ago
- daeken 8y agoI don't mind product placement, so long as it doesn't take away from my suspension of disbelief. In general, I just don't mind ads; I mind terrible and intrusive ads, which traditional commercials absolutely are.
- zaarn 8y agoProduct placement, if well executed, is much less intrusive than ad spots. An ad spot interrupts the story and flow of whatever you're watching while you won't even notice a well placed product (Stranger Things Waffles, for example, are a rather good product placement)
- marmot777 8y agoExactly. The more unintrusive the better. Frankly, I'd rather have subtle, subliminal messaging then to be interrupted by an advertisement. Youtube interrupts with ads whereas I believe they used to front load the ads at the beginnng. I'd be way more inclined to respond favoribly to an ad for which I don't already have a negative association: breaking the flow of something I'm already watching. I can't imagine anyone getting interrupted then buying the product who's advertising just abruptly interrupted something. I wonder how the analytics work on ads meaning what do they consider a success? Just that the ad played? Some action by the user?
- zaarn 8y agoFrontloading is still a bit annoying IMO but much better than interruptions. If it needs to be a spot ad or sponsorship shoutout then it should IMO be at the end. Lots of youtubers do that and I usually already tuned out when it gets to that point so it'll only hit interested people.
- JadeNB 8y ago> Youtube interrupts with ads whereas I believe they used to front load the ads at the beginnng. I'd be way more inclined to respond favoribly to an ad for which I don't already have a negative association: breaking the flow of something I'm already watching. Just like web browsing after ad blocking as compared to before, I've found that using youtube-dl (https://youtube-dl.org https://youtube-dl.org) just a few times has made me way less patient with this junk whenever I accidentally navigate to the official site. > I can't imagine anyone getting interrupted then buying the product who's advertising just abruptly interrupted something. I wonder how the analytics work on ads meaning what do they consider a success? Just that the ad played? Some action by the user? My impression has always been that there is almost no visible penalty for failure in advertising—you can't easily track the people who didn't buy your product because of an irritating ad—that even what must be the tiny success rate is deemed worth the investment. (I think that also advertisers are in the same boat, relative to this, as consumers are: we want our products cheap, and manufacturers would rather keep them apparently cheap by loading hidden costs (like data gathering and advertising) on us than actually charge us what they're work; and advertisers, presumably, want their ads to work, so the networks would rather use whatever extreme and scummy trick is available if it appears to give them a short-term advantage over other networks than acknowledge the ineffectiveness of that technique.)
- marmot777 8y agoI find the auto play of the promotional video that's always at the top of Netflix to be super annoying; however, once I'm watching something, advertising's unobtrusive. I'd rather have product placement than interruption marketing.
- chunkyslink 8y agoThe BBC does not run intrusive ads. Product placement is not intrusive at all.
- deadbunny 8y agoThe BBC is funded via the TV License, they're not a commercial broadcaster.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoSome examples of intrusive product placement: https://youtu.be/oQYwFND7rHE https://youtu.be/oQYwFND7rHE https://youtu.be/ca6W7peL6s4 https://youtu.be/ca6W7peL6s4 https://youtu.be/J8T2kZ8f6BA https://youtu.be/J8T2kZ8f6BA Especially bad when they make a character say or do something that doesn’t fit with their persona to shoehorn mention of a brand. Maybe it’s me getting older, but I can’t help but notice product placement, speeding up of shows, Netflix doing the opposite by stretching out shows with useless filler scenes, story arcs introducing unnecessary and tacked on side plots to increase # of seasons, extra sexual and gore content to shock. It really ruins watching media for me. The last one I really liked was Breaking Bad I think.
- thinkloop 8y ago> https://youtu.be/oQYwFND7rHE https://youtu.be/oQYwFND7rHE Wow, that's really pushing the definition of product "placement". That needs another term like "in-show commercial".
- icebraining 8y agoIt's not the only one on that show: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfHuZ5qrYX4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfHuZ5qrYX4
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThose examples should credit Ford and Subway as director. :) I'm the same. The Netflix version of Black Mirror loses so much impact from the addition of 20 mins of dead filler. Don't forget overly long and overblown fight and chase scenes that all movies must now have. They just bore me senseless. The first one I saw was fun, probably Blues Brothers, but even back then they were taking the mickey. Never the choreography and humour of Bruce Lee or Jackie Chan. Nowadays at home when a movie starts a fight against the hero, or the car (spaceship) chase I tend to do something else for 5. Breaking Bad was the best series to come out the US in ages. Even they lost the plot with the insanely long shootout with infinite ammo and insanely bad marksmanship. Thankfully that was a one off so very easy to forgive. :) Brit series go too far the other way and cram far too much into too few episodes. I've been enjoying Last Kingdom but boy are they spoiling it by cramming two books into every season, with fewer episodes per series compared to the US average.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI remember days where there’s we’re no ads on cable tv as that was one of the selling points. Also used to be no ads in theatres. I can’t fathom why anyone would pay money to see ads. I’ve been cable free for a decade and could never go back. Won’t even if you pay me to. Nope.
- bachmeier 8y agoActually, as the quality of service continues to decline, it will bring traditional cable TV to an end that much faster. For the most part, people don't accept this stuff, and they're rapidly moving away from it.
- verelo 8y agoThis shocks me too. I’d at least like the option to turn off ads for an additional fee. No way will i pay and watch ads however!
- Shivetya 8y agosix of one, half dozen of another. It can add up pretty quick if you subscribe to more than a few streaming services and with many groups going their own way we might likely end up back with group providers. What makes the cable free work for us is that it felt odd in this day an age to have internet and cable as both are effectively a transport method. Why cannot the cable provider stream over my internet connection at a discounted rate? on a site note about speeding up shows, when watching most informational videos on youtube you can speed them up to 1.25 speed with no real loss in quality. some presenters are a bit long winded
- dazc 8y agoAmazon's ads for their own shows and services on Prime are becoming gradually more intrusive though. I wouldn't be surprised to see regular ad slots being introduced at some point in time?
- scarface74 8y agoWhen we lived in an apartment, we were required to pay $99 for an Internet + cable bundle with Comcast. It sucked so badly that one of the deciding factors when we bought a house was that AT&T Fiber was available. We also had every bedroom, the office, and the living room wired for gigabit Ethernet with the expectation that we would be using only internet based video services. Now, we have three Roku TVs and two 4K AppleTV boxes (thanks to DirecTVNow). We subscribe to Netflix (free with T-mobile), DirecTVNow, and Hulu. My dad came up and he loved our RokuTV so I bought him one. He likes it, but he would never go cable free. With cable, you just turn it on and start watching. With the Roku TV, you have to sign up for an account, add channels, login to all of your subscriptions. If you have cable, you have to login to all of the different channels with your cable subscription. WiFi is also more flakey then cable. Then on top of that, they have to worry about going over thier 400Gb cap. Can you imagine most 70+ year olds having to go through all of the hassle with five TVs? Heck, except for the RokuTV, all of thier TVs are CRTs, including one that I bought for myself when I moved out in the mid 90s.
- maxerickson 8y agoSpectrum has "cable box in a browser" these days, so no need to fuss around with individual channels to watch on a computer. It's flash, not sure it would run on a Roku.
- scarface74 8y agoThe AppleTV experience is better. You sign in to your provider once, and other apps - with your permission - can use your cable login. The App Store will also suggest apps you are elibke for based on your cable package and which nes you can get if you upgrade your package. But, that’s a separate box and remote he would have to deal with.
- Jyaif 8y agoI think most 70+ year olds do not have five TVs.
- scarface74 8y ago
- legopelle 8y agoTwo things shook me while watching TV on my USA trip. One is the sheer number of ad breaks in programming. Here in Sweden there's only a few with a good chunk in between. The second is ads during programs. I mean not even having the courtesy to pause but instead overimpose. I sort of get it now why USA import shows have the weird breaks though. Given, I seldom watch TV here anymore, so I might be mistaken.
- mrfusion 8y agoI remember a scene on the simpsons where marge stopped mid conversation and got a broom and swept up all the ads on the bottom of the screen.
- marmot777 8y agoThere are millions of people who keep the TV running ALL THE TIME as in it's almost never turned off.
- madengr 8y agoThat’s insane. I can’t even think coherently with a TV in the background.
- marmot777 8y agoTrying to understand on why phones are so dangerous combined with driving, now killing more people each year than drunks behind the wheel, research's been done showing people can't really multitask, only switch tasks rapidly. We end up doing a half assed job on everything, including being present for other people whether other drives whose life depends on you being sober and focused but also friends and relatives. I've seen countless parents focused on their phones not paying attention to their kids, which is really sad. It's craziness as people could be much more productive if they did one thing at a time. That said, people who have the television running all the time probably aren't seeking to optimize their productivity.
- cptskippy 8y ago> I sort of get it now why USA import shows have the weird breaks though. That's a direct result of networks dictating the # of commercial breaks in the show. Watching a show like Battlestar Galactica is a bit odd because they liked to have dramatic little climaxes right before a commercial break.
- xstephen95x 8y agoin NYC, internet+cable and just internet were the exact same price, so..
- jpmattia 8y agoSome folks here may not be old enough to remember: Cable originally started without ads. The revenue stream proved to be too juicy to ignore. There's probably a prediction in there about Amazon/Netflix/etc.