4 ms·
This specific case aside, I don't understand what the big deal with euthanasia is in more clear-cut cases. Why is it not possible for terminal cancer patients (
by lucb1e 8y ago
This specific case aside, I don't understand what the big deal with euthanasia is in more clear-cut cases. Why is it not possible for terminal cancer patients (or similar terminal diseases) abroad? It seems we have run this long enough to prove that, yes, it is possible to run this system without apparent abuse.
And in this specific case, please keep in mind that it is so exceptional that it made international news. Both the Netherlands (RTL, as mentioned) reported on it as well as apparently the BBC. It's not as if we go along with every teen's death wish, and as the article says, "the process can take years". It's on the long side rather than short, as you have all the time in the world to reconsider, but also all the time in the world to suffer more. My grandfather had it finally arranged and was looking forward to it, but it was scheduled for a week after he died naturally. Poor man. This really is not about giving up on someone or saying someone doesn't deserve to live.
- kodablah 8y ago> It seems we have run this long enough to prove that, yes, it is possible to run this system without apparent abuse. Careful extrapolating successes/failures across cultures. Different peoples and different societies are much more amenable to abuse than others. It's less about their innate humanness and more about the societal structures in which they live and justified/unjustified faith (or lack of) in institutions and oversight bodies.
- paulddraper 8y ago> I don't understand what the big deal with euthanasia is in more clear-cut cases Is it avoided/discouraged because it is an irrevocable act. Many people believe that murderers "deserve" death and yet are reluctant to systemically end the lives of convicts even in "clear cut cases." What if the process, despite it being slow and deliberate and involved still gets it wrong?
- daveFNbuck 8y agoForcing someone to die slowly in agony is also an irrevocable act. There's more than one way to get it wrong.
- paulddraper 8y agoYeah, same with making someone rot in prison for a lifetime. I understand that.
- klondike_ 8y agoThe main argument I've heard against euthanasia (excluding religious ones) is that it may induce an obligation or pressure for terminally ill people to die. People with terminal diseases can be a financial and emotional burden on their family and society, which may cause family members or doctors to coerce patients to be euthanized. So far, in places where euthanasia is legal, this isn't the case. I doubt it ever will be, but I can understand how people can fear widespread euthanasia for that reason.
- candiodari 8y agoWorse than that, it can provide an avenue for people who commit crimes to ... shall we say encourage what, for them, would be a solution.