4 ms·
Yes. Also, you can refute all you want, but if the bad ideas are better clickbait than your refutations, they will spread faster.
by mirimir 8y ago
Yes.
Also, you can refute all you want, but if the bad ideas are better clickbait than your refutations, they will spread faster.
- reader5000 8y agoMaybe there's a reason a "bad idea" is clickbait.
- true_religion 8y agoHatred simply feels good. Unless you are saying that is something defensible or praiseworthy, then I am not sure where you are going with this thread of thought.
- reader5000 8y agoWho gets to determine what is "hatred"? The natural upvote/downvote economy of the internet or a self-appointed anonymous class of bigtech mass-censors? When you go on the internet would you prefer to see reality or an artificial selection of on-canon content pre-approved by the priest-media class as in the age of television? In many ways it doesn't matter because infotech decentralization will slowly find a way, and forcible censorship will no longer be possible.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoWhoa there buddy, there's other options for moderation besides media-priests || free market. How about we just let the people who own the machines decide what data sits on their machines? So I agree, decentralization will allow some communities to be total free market reddits and chans where anything goes, and I expect them to be very unpleasant places to hang out for some and not others. I'll be over here in my private community where Microsoft can't read my discussions and anyone whining about the priest-media will be booted.
- Whitestrake 8y agoWith more decentralization comes more freedom of association; I will choose to be a part of communities that I judge to have a reasonable view of what is "hatred", and those communities will, just like they do today, kick out offenders. Decentralization will give people the opportunity to spread their hatred among themselves, without involving me, which is... exactly how things operate today. So... Bring on infotech decentralization, I guess. It's got its merits, and for me, nothing about all this hate speech will change.
- mirimir 8y agoThat's almost a truism, no?
- reader5000 8y agoIndeed.
- Whitestrake 8y agoCan't think of a better explanation than this video by CGP Grey, titled "This Video Will Make You Angry", [7:26]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc
- specialist 8y agoA lie is half-way around the world before the truth has its pants on. — Mark Twain Younger me was a free speech ultimatist. Alas, human nature. Propaganda works, so well that people aren’t even aware of changing their minds. Overton windows. Blowback, where refuting further cements the falsehood. Belief as attire. Etc, etc.
- weberc2 8y agoI agree, but I also think there’s some effect of censorship that drives people toward the censored idea. Part of it is a rebellion against authority (“who are YOU to tell ME what ideas are fit or unfit to consume?”); I think there’s some related effect that is driving Trump’s popularity—some people are rebelling against the cultural authority of the left (by which I mean major news publications, entertainment media, university faculty, social media companies, etc—powerful cultural institutions). Another problem is what happens when bad actors come into power and get to do the censoring? We’ve just handed them a nice precedent, have we not?
- webmaven 8y ago> there’s some effect of censorship that drives people toward the censored idea. Not successful censorship per-se, but attempted censorship. See the "Streisand Effect": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- candiodari 8y agoAnd, as has been clearly illustrated, "trusted" news source can't always be trusted either. So preventing "lies" (lie is almost always a matter of perspective) to spread ... is really always also preventing people from finding out the truth. We just used to find that acceptable. Wars have been started by fake news from "reputable" sources. If fake news regulations become widespread and usable, they would be trivially easy for the rich and the government to abuse for censorship. Can you imagine how this would have gone had the president had the ability to prevent "fake news" from spreading ? https://globalnews.ca/news/4209011/trump-immigrant-animal-fake-news/ https://globalnews.ca/news/4209011/trump-immigrant-animal-fa... (I would argue that in Europe this "fake news" censorship is in fact pretty much normal. Only ... a part of the fake news isn't fake at all, but rather embarrassing to the government. The situation with rioting in French cities is 100x worse than sites like "Le Monde" report (which ones? Let's just say any > 1 mil ppl and there's only a few you'd be wrong about. Nice is pretty damn bad, for instance. Destruction in the city center every friday. You should see the security measures shops are taking, wtf). And other things that the government doesn't like get extremely downplayed as well : France was pretty much shut down due to a student strike in Paris for Macron's labor laws 3 times, and twice for his agricultural policy (both of which are downright abusive, and I'd say the protests were very justified) ... and there was a small mention of a protest march in Le Monde. Mass car torchings are a weekly occurrence since 2005 or so where I live. It baffles me, but it really looks like they're literally doing this just to save face for that asshole Macron. I get it ... I get it. He "saved Europe", especially after Brexit. He also fucked up France, and that matters more to me, and should matter more to French media and French voters. It's absurd because there literally isn't a single person in France that doesn't know these events happen, so what's the point of keeping them out of newspapers ? Do they think people will just forget ?)
- jarfil 8y agoThat's why refutations also need to be good clickbait. But of course that requires good communicators, while many people with in-depth knowledge are not even mediocre ones.
- webmaven 8y agoFor refutations to be both true and better clickbait requires not merely good communicators, but excellent or even world-class communicators, to adequately satisfy both sets of constraints. Meanwhile, bullshitters have a much easier job. eg. the creationist argument "If evolution is true, why are there still monkeys?" doesn't even make sense, it just sounds good, confirms existing bias, conveys the (false) feeling of understanding, etc. As a result, it is unfortunately very persuasive, and continues to spread much faster than the refutations, which aren't as simple and don't give the same superficial "aha" jolt of satisfaction. In fact, the closest I've come to a refutation that works as well is "well, if selective breeding of dogs is true, why do we still have wolves?", but of course then you still have to follow up with one or more examples of natural selection mechanisms & the idea of non-uniform environments (more small and fast prey over here, dry and cold weather over there, etc.), or you're inadvertently confirming their bias by introducing an intelligent selecting agency as part of your argument.