3 ms·
So? Laugh at them, and then contribute facts. Next. At any given time, these things are all part of the conversation. Suppressing them only adds to the allu
by ddingus 8y ago
So?
Laugh at them, and then contribute facts.
Next.
At any given time, these things are all part of the conversation. Suppressing them only adds to the allure.
Attempting to manage it, "for their own good" will not end well, and it won't end well because way too many people will fail to trust, share that and undermine it all.
As they should. That problem is why there is a First Amendment in the first place. I know that does not apply here, and I know why too.
Not my intent.
The dynamics that lead to having a First Amendment are my point.
The moment people begin to mistrust, and that catches fire and spreads is the moment the dialog gets toxic and hostile.
See my comment up thread.
- mrguyorama 8y agoAnd people like my mother? Who didn't do so well in statistics and science and math and therefore do not have the tools to rationally judge one claim versus another? How do we help them not get pulled into, often alluring and attractive, circles of hate?
- ddingus 8y agoI love you mom, but those people are fucking clowns. How can I help? (Have had this exact exchange. Took a while, but did resolve. Human problems take human work.)
- anigbrowl 8y agoLane Davis's dad tried that approach, arguing to his son that he (the son) had fallen down a neo-nazi rabbit hole. Davis denounced his dad as a 'leftist pedophile' and stabbed him to death. I could supply a laundry list of examples, but the basic point I'd like to communicate is that once someone signs up to an eliminationist philosophy we have (to misquote Churchill) established what they are, and the only question is in what order they intend to pursue that project. I want to be careful here to distinguish between ideas that mre merely wrong and those that involve imposition of their calculus upon others. For example, I consider flat earthers ridiculous but it's not like they are threatening to flatten out anything they consider overly curved.
- ddingus 8y agoIf it's actually criminal speech, enforce the law. If it's not actually criminal speech, the answer is more speech.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThat's a very nice platitude, but as reality has shown, it's a terrible rule.
- ddingus 8y agoIt's not a platitude. And it's actually quite a good rule, when enforced consistently. That was not done in recent cases. And, like I said. I'm just going to watch it play out. I'll be on the tail end of this thing to talk about it then. When people are more receptive.
- ddingus 8y agoLet's just say I am not getting upvotes on this. :D Rather than actually have a real discussion, people prefer to "solve the problem." It won't go well. I will bow out of this discussion for now. There are places where a real conversation can be had, and this isn't one of them.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoNo, you're being pointed out that you're wrong. That "more speech" doesn't help, and can actually get people killed.
- ddingus 8y agoI have no complaints about the discussion I can see. I have no desire to go through Karma on people who would just rather down vote because they don't like what they read. Personally, I almost never downvote, would much rather engage and have a chat about things. Most of the time that happens here, on this topic it's obviously not. And the whole thing is by no means definitive. I happen to have a very significant amount of experience with this. If the speech is Criminal, then it can get people killed, (among other non trivial harm) so apply the law. Secondly, apply the law where it needs to be applied. Using a bludgeon, where Precision Instruments are more effective, only makes a bigger mess than intended. There is a huge difference between, "fuck this guy we're done", and we're removing these because you're over the line. Even worse, what was done to Jones, is the bludgeon. And it was done without the precision, and consistent action needed to give the feedback necessary to justify and help people understand what just happened. There will be negative and severe implications from all of that. It may seem fine now, but some precedents were just set, lines crossed. I'm not sure people thought that all through. Some important trust was just lost. That stuff is different from speech that isn't Criminal, where the answer is more speech. It is also a matter of people learning to use all the tools they have, not just righteous indignation. I'm not wrong at all. However, I can tell the dominant mode here is some people think they can control other people. They also happen to think they know best for others, neither of which is true. At the same time, recognizing our own personal agency in conversation, and educating people about that, and all the good it can do, is being near completely ignored in this discussion. That's an error. And they are just going to have to learn the hard way. I'll Stand By and Watch. Wrote this on voice, sorry for the various spelling and other errors in this comment.
- dahdum 8y agoI know you're sincere, but do you see the danger in what you just said? Restricting ideas your mother can hear, based on your assessment of her competency to understand them "properly"? That's a very dark path that does not lead to utopia.